Home › Preserving › Pickled Onions
Pickled Onions
Remove the skins from small white onions with a silver knife. Pack in washed and dried cans, adding six to ten chili peppers and two tablespoonfuls of white mustard seed to each jar. Fill the jars to overflow with cold vinegar and tighten the covers at once.
This is a raw-pack, unprocessed shelf pickle, and it falls outside every current guideline for home canning. The points below explain what specifically fails.
- No acidity is measured or guaranteedSafe pickling depends on vinegar of at least 5 percent acetic acid, used in a tested proportion to the vegetable. Household vinegar of the period varied widely in strength, and the recipe specifies neither strength nor any dilution ratio, so the finished pH is unknown.
- Whole onions do not acidify quicklyA whole peeled onion is dense and layered. Vinegar poured cold over raw onions takes time to reach the centre, and until it does the interior can remain less acid than the surrounding liquid inside a closed jar — a condition under which Clostridium botulinum may be able to grow.
- No heat at any stageThe jars are washed and dried but not sterilised, the vinegar is cold, and there is no boiling-water process after filling. Nothing in the sequence destroys spoilage organisms or spores, and nothing drives out the air needed to form a vacuum.
- "Tighten the covers at once" does not make a sealScrewing a lid onto a cold jar traps air, and no vacuum is formed; whatever closure results can later flex or leak. A tight cover is not proof of preservation, and a jar of this kind stored in a pantry is unprocessed food in a closed container.
- No salt or brining stepTraditional English pickled onions are salted or brined for a day or more before the vinegar goes on, which draws out water that would otherwise dilute the vinegar in the jar. Skipping it lowers the final acidity further, by an amount the recipe gives no way to calculate.
- Terms in the original"Cans" here means glass canning jars, not tin; the recipe itself switches to "each jar." The silver knife is a long-standing kitchen habit meant to keep steel from blackening the cut onion — carbon steel did discolour pale vegetables, though modern stainless does not.
- If you want pickled onionsUse a current tested recipe from a reliable preserving authority, or make them as a refrigerator pickle and keep them cold. Do not adapt the proportions above.
Pickled onions belong to the English pickle tradition that American cookbooks inherited wholesale — small white or silverskin onions, whole spices, and strong vinegar, kept in stoneware or glass to be eaten with cold meat, bread and cheese. Books of this kind sit at an awkward moment: the equipment for real canning existed and was cheap, but the science did not yet, and authors still wrote as though a tight lid and enough vinegar were sufficient in themselves. Botulism is generally said to have been recognised as a hazard of home-canned vegetables in the United States only in the early twentieth century, and systematic processing times for pickles came later still. The chilies and white mustard seed are doing double duty here as flavouring and as a nod to the older belief that pungent spices helped keep a pickle sound — a notion generally traced to the long association between spices and preservation, rather than to any measured effect.