Home › Pastry Desserts › Orange Charlotte
Orange Charlotte
1/3 box gelatine or 1 1/3 tablespoons granulated gelatine 1/3 cup cold water 1/3 cup boiling water 1 cup sugar 3 tablespoons lemon juice 1 cup orange juice and pulp Whites 3 eggs Whip from 2 cups cream Soak gelatine in cold water, dissolve in boiling water, strain, and add sugar, lemon juice, orange juice, and pulp. Chill in pan of ice-water; when quite thick, beat with wire spoon or whisk until frothy, then add whites of eggs beaten stiff, and fold in cream. Line a mould with sections of oranges, turn in mixture, smooth evenly, and chill.
The gelatine base here is boiled and safe, but the finished charlotte is set cold with raw egg whites folded in and is never heated afterwards.
- Raw egg white is the problemThe whites go in beaten stiff and uncooked, and the mixture is only chilled. Nothing in the method reaches a temperature that would kill Salmonella, which can be present inside intact shell eggs, and the sugar and gelatine offer no protection.
- Chilling is not a controlRefrigeration slows bacterial growth but does not eliminate it, and a moulded charlotte typically sits for hours before serving and again after. Any contamination introduced with the whites remains in the finished dessert.
- Who is most at riskUncooked-egg desserts are the classic vehicle for foodborne illness in children, pregnant women, older adults and anyone immunocompromised. This is exactly the sort of dish public health guidance has singled out for decades.
- The gelatine quantity is also unreliableThe gelatine measure needs translating — "1/3 box gelatine" refers to a period package, but the recipe supplies its own equivalent, about 1 1/3 tablespoons of granulated gelatine, which is the figure a modern cook would work from.
- If you want an orange charlotteUse a current recipe, one that either specifies pasteurised egg whites or builds the meringue by cooking the whites with hot syrup.
The charlotte russe family of desserts — a cold, set cream turned out of a lined mould — was a showpiece of late nineteenth-century American cookery, and this orange version uses the fruit both to flavour the jelly and to decorate the mould. Its rise plausibly owed something to two things arriving in ordinary kitchens: commercial gelatine, sold in boxes of leaves or granules rather than boiled down from calves' feet at home, and dependable ice for the "pan of ice-water" the recipe calls for at the crucial thickening stage. The instruction to beat the half-set jelly until frothy before folding in whites and whipped cream is what gives the dish its light, spongy body; the note "whip from 2 cups cream" is period shorthand meaning the whip skimmed off two cups of cream as it is beaten, not two cups of finished whipped cream.