Home › The Waldorf Kitchen › Apple Custard Pudding
Apple Custard Pudding
Stew some good large cooking-apples (pared, cored and minced) in a little water; when done, rub through a coarse sieve and sweeten. Make a good custard of milk, eggs and powdered sugar, with a little lemon flavoring. Pour the apples into a pudding-dish and the custard mixture on top of the apples, and put in a slow oven to bake about half an hour until done.
Oscar gives proportions for nothing here, which is normal for a professional's notebook — the cook was expected to know what a "good custard" was. The points below fill in the numbers and the one detail that decides whether this sets or curdles.
- The hinge: gentle heatA baked custard sets at about 175-180F internally and curdles above roughly 185F. Keep the oven low and pull the pudding when the centre still trembles slightly; it firms as it cools.
- "A slow oven"300 to 325F. At that temperature half an hour is realistic only for a shallow dish; a deeper one will want 45 minutes to an hour.
- Water bathNot mentioned, but a roasting pan of hot water reaching halfway up the pudding dish is the standard professional insurance against a grainy, weeping custard, and it costs nothing.
- Working proportionsAbout 1 1/2 lb apples cooked down to a thick puree, sweetened to taste, and a custard of 2 cups whole milk, 4 eggs (or 3 eggs plus a yolk), and 1/3 cup sugar. Serves four to six.
- Cooking applesPeriod "cooking-apples" means a tart variety that collapses when stewed, or otherwise put: Bramley if you can get it, otherwise McIntosh. Stew in the barest film of water; a wet puree thins the custard and encourages the two layers to marble.
- Powdered sugarIn this era the term usually means finely ground granulated sugar, not the cornstarch-cut confectioners' sugar sold today. Use regular granulated or superfine.
- Lemon flavoringGrated zest steeped in the warm milk and strained out gives a cleaner result than bottled extract. About a teaspoon of zest for 2 cups of milk.
- The sieveA coarse sieve was one of the usual puree tools. A food mill or a few pulses in a processor does the same job; avoid working it to a smooth glue, since a little texture is what distinguishes this from a plain custard.
Apples under or over custard is one of the oldest patterns in English and American dessert cookery. Oscar Tschirky's 1896 Cook Book ran to over nine hundred pages and included a great many plain domestic puddings alongside the Waldorf's showpieces. The extreme brevity here is characteristic: a stewed fruit base, a standard custard, a slow oven, and the assumption that the reader has made a custard before.