Home › The Waldorf Kitchen › Milk Toast
Milk Toast
Toast slices of stale bread to a delicate color; meanwhile heat to the boiling point a sufficient quantity of milk to saturate the toast, adding two tablespoonfuls of butter to each pint of milk. When the milk boils, pour it over the toast, and serve at once. The boiling milk may be thickened with a little flour.
A four-line recipe whose success rests almost entirely on timing: the toast must meet the milk at the table, not in the kitchen.
- Stale bread is the pointDay-old bread has lost enough moisture to absorb hot milk without collapsing. Fresh sandwich bread turns to paste within seconds; a firm white loaf, cut about half an inch thick and dried out overnight, holds its structure.
- "A delicate color"Pale gold, not brown. Dark toast turns bitter once it is soaked, and the burnt notes come forward rather than receding.
- QuantitiesA pint is 2 cups; 2 tablespoons of butter per pint is generous. Figure roughly a cup of milk to two slices of toast, which gives one serving. The recipe itself specifies no yield.
- Do not let the milk sitScalded milk forms a skin and catches on the pan bottom within a minute or two of boiling. Bring it just to the boil, off the heat, and pour immediately.
- Thickening with flourThe optional flour is best handled as a thin white sauce rather than a slurry stirred into boiling milk, which will lump. Cook a scant tablespoon of flour in the butter for a minute, then whisk in the pint of milk and bring it up.
- SeasoningThe original mentions none, and it needs salt — about a quarter teaspoon per pint of milk. Some later versions add a grating of nutmeg or a little sugar, both period-appropriate.
- AssemblyWarm the bowls, lay in the toast, pour the milk over at the last moment and carry it straight out. Milk toast that has stood five minutes is a different and much worse dish.
Milk toast belongs to the long tradition of invalid cookery — food for the sick, the elderly, the very young, and anyone recovering from too much of everything else. Nineteenth-century household manuals and hospital diet lists carried it constantly, alongside beef tea, gruel and arrowroot, on the reasoning that bread softened in hot milk was nourishing and required nothing of the digestion. Its appearance in a Waldorf-Astoria collection is a reminder that a grand hotel kitchen fed staff, children and unwell guests in their rooms as well as sending out terrapin and canvasback downstairs. The dish survived into the twentieth century largely through nostalgia and the sickroom; 'milk toast' came to suggest a mild, unassertive person, an association cemented by H. T. Webster's cartoon character Caspar Milquetoast.