Home › The Waldorf Kitchen › Preserved Apples
Preserved Apples
Core, pare and slice some pippins and put to each pound of apples half a pound of preserving-sugar, and to each eight pounds thus sweetened, one quart of water together with a few cloves and the thin rind and juice of a lemon. Stew till the apples are clear, and put up in wide-mouthed bottles or jars for future use.
The stewing itself is unremarkable, but the last clause — "put up in wide-mouthed bottles or jars for future use" — is where this recipe stops being usable. It is a shelf-stable preserve with no processing step, no seal specified, and a sugar level well below what would make it self-preserving.
- No processing, no sealThe recipe ends with the hot fruit going into open-mouthed jars. There is no boiling-water bath, no processing time, no headspace, and no description of how the jar is closed. Nothing here establishes a vacuum seal or destroys spoilage organisms in the filled jar.
- The sugar is too dilute to preserveHalf a pound of sugar per pound of apples, plus a quart of water for every eight pounds, gives a finished syrup weaker than jam or a true conserve even after some of the water boils off in stewing. Sugar preserves by binding water; at this concentration there is likely to be free water left for yeasts and moulds.
- Mould and yeast, not botulismApples are acidic enough that Clostridium botulinum is not the main worry. The realistic outcome of an unprocessed, under-sugared fruit preserve stored at room temperature is fermentation and surface mould, and some moulds on stored fruit produce mycotoxins that are not removed by scraping or by reheating.
- Store-bought "pippins"Pippin is a loose old term for an apple raised from seed, and came to be attached to firm, sharp keeping varieties; several named pippins survive, among them Newtown Pippin and Cox's Orange Pippin. Any tart, firm apple that holds its shape — Bramley, Granny Smith, Braeburn — is what the recipe is after.
- Preserving-sugarA coarse-crystal cane sugar sold for jam-making because it dissolves slowly and throws less scum. It contains no added pectin, unlike modern "jam sugar", and plain granulated sugar is its equivalent.
- If you want this fruitStewed spiced apples with lemon and clove are worth making, but consult a current tested recipe for either refrigerated short-term storage or properly processed canning. Do not follow the storage instruction given here.
Preserved fruit in sugar syrup was a standing item in nineteenth-century household books. The clove-and-lemon-rind flavouring is an old English convention for apples, traceable through the same line of cookery writing that produced apple butter and quince paste; the lemon supplied acid and aroma, the cloves a warmth that also masked the flat taste of long-stored fruit. What the recipe reveals about its period is the assumption behind that final sentence: home preserving was still passed on as a technique rather than a set of numbers, and a cook was expected to know from her own kitchen how full to fill a jar and how to close it. Reliable, tested processing schedules for fruit at home came largely out of twentieth-century agricultural extension work, which is exactly why the instruction here reads as complete to its author and incomplete to us.