Home › The Waldorf Kitchen › Roasted Saddle of Lamb
Roasted Saddle of Lamb
The saddle of lamb is simply the two loins cut off before the carcass is split open down the back; it is best when roasted before an open fire, but it may be cooked in a very hot oven. If medium size it will cook in an hour and a half, but if large it will require two hours. It should first be exposed to intense heat until browned, then seasoned with salt and pepper, and every fifteen minutes should be basted with the drippings, which fall from it; about a half hour before the loin is done make a sauce for it as follows: Peel two large cucumbers, cut them in slices, and place them in salted cold water. Peel and slice one medium-sized onion, place it in a saucepan with the cucumbers, with enough gravy to cover, and let them stew for fifteen minutes; season highly with salt and pepper and a tablespoonful of lemon-juice or vinegar. When the lamb is cooked dish it on a hot dish, garnish with cucumbers, and serve the sauce in a gravy-boat with it.
Roasted Saddle and Leg of Lamb Wash, salt and flour the meat and put it in a bakingpan in a hot oven to roast, basting often until done. Place it on a hot dish and serve it with mint sauce.
A butcher's cut and an open-hearth timing, both of which need translation. The saddle is worth ordering, but the roasting times here belong to an era that liked lamb cooked through.
- The cutA saddle is the two loins still joined across the backbone, taken before the carcass is split — essentially a double loin roast, often around 4 to 6 lb once the flaps are trimmed. It is rarely a retail case item; ask a butcher for a whole saddle of lamb, bone in, and have the kidneys and excess fat removed.
- "A very hot oven"Roughly 450 to 500F. The recipe's sequence — intense heat to brown, then seasoning and basting — is close to a sear-and-roast: give it 15 to 20 minutes at that heat to brown, season, then drop to 350F for the remainder.
- Time versus temperatureNinety minutes to two hours will take a saddle well past grey. Roast to an internal reading of 130 to 135F at the thickest part of the loin, away from bone, for medium-rare — typically 50 to 70 minutes total for a 5 lb saddle. Rest it 15 minutes before carving.
- BastingEvery fifteen minutes is sound advice with a lean loin, but each opening of a modern oven drops the temperature sharply. Baste twice rather than five times, and add a little stock to the pan if the drippings threaten to scorch.
- "Enough gravy to cover"Here this most likely means brown stock or the day's jus rather than a thickened sauce. Use lamb or veal stock, or the strained pan drippings loosened with stock.
- The cucumber sauceThe sliced cucumbers sit in salted cold water; drain them well before stewing or the sauce will be watery. Fifteen minutes of stewing gives a soft, almost melting cucumber; if you want the garnish slices to hold shape, cook those separately and briefly.
- CarvingA saddle is carved either in long strips parallel to the backbone or crosswise into thick cutlets. Either way, run a knife down each side of the spine first to free the loins from the bone.
- YieldNot stated. A medium saddle serves six to eight as a main course.
- The second recipeThe brief "Roasted Saddle and Leg of Lamb" that follows is the plain household version — flour the meat, hot oven, mint sauce — and it covers the leg as well as the saddle. The same internal temperatures apply.
Oscar Tschirky's book, published in 1896, sits at the point where hearth roasting was passing out of American practice: he still names the open fire as best and treats the oven as the concession, a distinction that is often said to have faded from cookbooks a generation later. The saddle itself is a butcher's and banquet cut, broken down differently from the start. The cucumber sauce is worth noting: mint sauce was already the reflexive English accompaniment to lamb, and the second, plainer recipe on this page duly calls for it, while the cucumber-and-onion stew reflects the French service Oscar had learned in New York's dining rooms.