Home › The Waldorf Kitchen › Venetian Jelly
Venetian Jelly
Put one ounce of soaked gelatine into a saucepan with three-fourths of a pint of hot water and place it over the fire until dissolved; then add one-fourth pound of coarsely-crushed loaf sugar and the juice of three lemons. Beat the whites and shells of three eggs, stir them into the jelly and boil for five minutes longer. Remove the jelly from the fire, strain it and mix in three wineglassfuls of sherry and one wineglassful of brandy. Decorate the interior of a plain mould with small pieces of candied peel, dipping them in the jelly to make them stick, then half-fill the mould with the jelly and leave until set. Put one-half ounce of soaked gelatine in a saucepan with one-half pint of milk and two ounces of sugar; stir over the fire until dissolved; then move it to the side and mix in quickly the beaten yolks of two eggs. Move the custard away from the fire and allow it to cool. Moisten one-half pound of sponge cakes with as much sherry as they will absorb, then lay them on the top of the set jelly in the mould; when the custard has sufficiently cooled fill the mould up with it and place it on ice for an hour or two. When ready, dip the mould in tepid water, wipe dry and turn it out onto a fancy dish.
A two-layer moulded jelly of the sort that anchored Victorian and Edwardian dessert service: a clarified lemon-sherry jelly below, a soaked-sponge and custard layer above. The measurements are pre-standard and the gelatine handling is the part that will decide whether it turns out.
- The hinge: don't boil the gelatine with the lemon juiceProlonged boiling in acid breaks gelatine down and the jelly will set weakly or not at all. The five-minute boil in the original exists to coagulate the egg white for clarifying; keep it at a bare simmer and no longer, or clarify with the whites in the sugar syrup before the gelatine goes in.
- Gelatine quantitiesOne ounce of gelatine is by weight roughly four ¼-oz envelopes of modern powdered gelatine, and the half ounce for the custard is two, though period gelatine was not of standardised strength. That points to a firm, sliceable set meant to survive being turned out and carried to table; if you want a softer spoonable jelly, cut both by about a quarter.
- Liquid measuresThree-fourths of a pint is 12 fl oz in American measure, and a half pint 8 fl oz. A wineglassful in this period is about 2 fl oz, so the jelly takes roughly 6 fl oz sherry and 2 fl oz brandy — added off the heat so the alcohol survives.
- Loaf sugarSugar was sold as a hard cone to be broken up; "coarsely-crushed loaf sugar" simply means lump sugar knocked apart. Use 4 oz granulated sugar for the jelly and 2 oz for the custard.
- Egg whites and shellsThis is the classic clarification: the coagulating albumen traps cloudy particles and floats them as a raft. Wash the shells well first, and strain through a scalded jelly bag or a double layer of cheesecloth without squeezing, or you push the sediment back through.
- The custardYolks stirred into hot milk off the heat are not reliably cooked. Return the pan to low heat and stir until the custard thickens and registers 175°F, then cool it before it meets the set jelly — pouring warm custard onto the jelly will melt the surface and blur the layers.
- Sponge cakesSmall individual sponges or ladyfingers, not a modern layer cake. Half a pound is about 20 ladyfingers; moisten them rather than soak them to collapse.
- Chilling and unmouldingAn hour or two on ice is optimistic for a mould this size — give it four hours or overnight in the refrigerator. Dip briefly in tepid water, not hot, wipe the mould dry, and invert onto a chilled dish.
- YieldA 1½-quart mould, serving eight to ten as part of a larger dessert course.
Oscar Tschirky, maître d'hôtel of the Waldorf and later the Waldorf-Astoria, published his Cook Book in 1896, and its dessert chapters preserve the moulded-jelly repertoire that hotel kitchens inherited from mid-century English confectionery manuals. "Venetian" here reads as a fashion label rather than a claim of Italian origin — city names (Venetian, Muscovite, Neapolitan) were attached to moulds and ices in this period, though no consistent rule governed their use — and the candied-peel lining and sherry-soaked sponge place the dish in the family of trifles, charlottes and wine jellies rather than anything traceable to Venice. What the recipe really records is the labour a hotel kitchen could spend on a single dessert: clarifying jelly with egg white and shell, setting it in stages so the layers stay distinct, and cooling it on ice at a time when ice was bought by the block and a moulded jelly that arrived at table standing upright was itself the point.