Home › Soups › Meatless Bean Soup
Meatless Bean Soup
Parboil one pint beans, drain off the water, add fresh, let boil until perfectly tender, season with pepper and salt, add a piece of butter the size of a walnut, or more if preferred; when done skim out half the beans, leaving the broth with the remaining half in the kettle, now add a tea-cup sweet cream or good milk, a dozen or more crackers broken up; let it boil up, and serve.
A plain Lenten or economy soup that relies on the beans' own starch for body. Two things carry it: a genuinely long simmer, and holding back the milk until the very end.
- A pint of beansDry beans were measured by volume in period books, not weight; a pint is about 2 cups, roughly 14 oz. Any small white bean works — navy, great northern, cannellini. Yield will depend on how much fresh water you add, but expect enough for four to six.
- Parboil and drainThe instruction to boil once, throw off that water and start again is common in period bean cookery; the water carries off dusty or sour flavour from long storage, and incidentally some of the oligosaccharides that cause gas. Keep it, but do soak overnight first if you want the beans tender in an hour and a half rather than three.
- Perfectly tender means falling apartApart from the crackers added at the end, the collapsing beans are the body of the soup. The beans left in the kettle should give way when pressed with a spoon; if they still hold shape the broth stays thin. Older dry beans can take well over two hours.
- Butter the size of a walnutRoughly 1 to 2 tablespoons; a shelled walnut was one of several common period comparisons for a small lump of butter.
- A tea-cup of creamCommonly reckoned at about 3/4 cup, though period teacups varied and were rarely the 8 oz of a modern measuring cup. The recipe does say to let it boil up; cream takes that well, but thinner milk can separate, so keep it at a bare simmer if you substitute.
- The crackersA dozen soda or water crackers, broken small, act as the thickener and were expected to dissolve. Unsalted saltines or oyster crackers are the closest current equivalent; taste again for salt after they go in, since crackers carry their own.
- The skimmed-out halfReserving half the beans whole and returning them at the end gives texture against the thickened broth. You can also mash or blend the kettle half before adding the cream, which the original could not do as easily.
- SeasoningSalt, pepper and butter are all the recipe allows. If you want more, a bay leaf and an onion in the second water are within the idiom of period plain cooking; the point of "meatless" is that no ham hock or salt pork appears.
Bean soup thickened with broken crackers and finished with cream is a thrift dish that turns up across 19th-century American cookbooks, and the label "meatless" marks it out for weeks when there was no ham bone to spare — and, in some households, for fast days. The Dixie Cook Book, compiled in the 1880s from the same publishing tradition as the Buckeye books, sits at a moment when dried beans were still a staple winter protein and crackers were bought from the barrel rather than the sleeve. The trick of using crackers as a thickener — instead of a butter-and-flour roux — is characteristic of the period's plainer cooking, where a hard biscuit or cracker was the pantry item most reliably at hand.