Home › Our Susan's Opinion of a Kitchen › Turkey Soup
Turkey Soup
Anonymous.
Take the turkey bones and cook for one hour in water enough to cover them; then stir in a little dressing and a beaten egg. Take from the fire, and when the water has ceased boiling add a little butter with pepper and salt.
Four sentences that assume you already know what a stockpot is. The gaps worth filling are the meaning of "dressing," the short cooking time, and the egg.
- "Dressing" is stuffingIn American cookbooks of this period dressing means the bread stuffing cooked with the bird, not a salad dressing. A few spoonfuls act as the thickener here, so the soup's character depends entirely on how the stuffing was seasoned — sage and onion will dominate.
- One hour is thinAn hour will pull flavour from meat scraps but not from the bones themselves. Two to three hours at a bare simmer gets the gelatin out and gives the soup body; roast the carcass pieces again briefly first if the colour is pale.
- Water enough to coverCover the broken-up frame by an inch, no more. Whole carcass bones trap air and float, so crack or cut them down to keep the liquid volume honest — otherwise you are diluting rather than extracting.
- Strain before you finishThe original says nothing about it, but lift out the bones and strain through a sieve before adding dressing and egg. Turkey frames give up small sharp bone fragments after long cooking.
- Butter and seasoning lastSalt only at the end. Even the hour the recipe specifies concentrates whatever salt the roast bird carried, and stuffing is usually well salted already.
- Handling the carcassStrip and refrigerate or freeze the frame within two hours of carving. The recipe says nothing about how long the bones sat before they went into the pot.
- YieldAn average turkey frame with water to cover produces roughly two to three quarts before reduction.
This is scrap cookery, contributed anonymously to a community cookbook. The Home Cook Book was assembled in Chicago in the 1870s from recipes donated by local women, sold for charitable benefit, and reprinted widely — a format that favoured exactly this kind of terse, practical note passed between neighbours. Turkey was a holiday bird for most households, which meant the carcass arrived once or twice a year and was expected to earn its keep; using the leftover dressing as a thickener rather than making a fresh roux is the thrift instinct of the period in miniature. The egg-and-butter finish is an older enrichment technique that runs back through English cookery well before this book.