Home › Meat › Hot Roast Beef Sandwich
Hot Roast Beef Sandwich
Between thin slices of lightly buttered white bread place a thin slice of hot roast beef. Put two tablespoonfuls of brown gravy over top. Garnish with a pickle.
A one-line assembly note from a book of sandwich formulas, written for cooks who already had a roast and a gravy boat on hand. The only real decisions are heat and structure.
- The hinge: everything hot at onceThe hinge: get the beef hot -- The recipe specifies hot roast beef, and gravy poured over cool beef on cool bread makes a damp, tepid sandwich rather than a hot one; carve the meat straight from the joint or lay it in the simmering gravy for a few seconds before plating.
- "Brown gravy"Generally pan drippings thickened with flour and thinned with stock, in proportions that varied from cook to cook. Two tablespoonfuls per sandwich is about 1 fl oz, enough to gloss the top slice without collapsing it.
- Bread choiceOlder-style white sandwich bread tended to be firmer and drier than most modern soft loaves. A close-crumbed white bread or a lightly toasted slice will hold the gravy; airy supermarket bread turns to paste.
- Why butter under gravyButter also acts as waterproofing: a thin, complete film on the cut face slows the gravy soaking through, useful here whether or not that was the reason for the instruction.
- Carving"Thin" means genuinely thin — beef sliced thick enough to need chewing will pull out of the sandwich in one piece. Slice across the grain, and if the meat has been refrigerated, slice it cold and reheat the slices in the gravy.
- The pickleA cucumber pickle, most likely a sweet gherkin or a dill spear, split lengthwise and set alongside. It is doing the job of acid against a rich, fatty plate, so a sharp pickle serves better than a mild one.
- YieldAs written, one sandwich. Scale by the slice; a cup of gravy dresses about eight.
The hot beef sandwich under gravy belongs to the era when a Sunday roast was expected to reappear at several later meals, and cookbooks devoted whole chapters to the tactful reuse of cold joints. Small single-subject books like this one proliferated in the United States around the turn of the twentieth century, when the lunch counter and the packed office dinner both pushed the sandwich from a picnic item toward a category of its own — hence a volume of nothing but sandwiches, arranged by filling. This particular formula belongs to the same family as the diner "hot beef" plate, which by mid-century had migrated onto a fork-and-knife platter with mashed potatoes and gravy poured over the lot; the version here is still a hand-held sandwich, restrained to two tablespoonfuls of gravy and a pickle on the side.