Home › Supper › Vanity Biscuits
Vanity Biscuits
One pint flour, one pint milk, three eggs, one-half teaspoon of salt.
This is a proportion rather than a method — the sort of shorthand a nineteenth-century cook could read at a glance. The ratio (equal volumes flour and milk, three eggs, no leavening) is the popover formula, and everything about handling it follows from that.
- The hinge: steam, not leaveningThere is no soda, baking powder or yeast here. The rise comes entirely from water in the milk and eggs flashing to steam inside a thin, elastic batter, so the pan and the oven must both be hot when the batter goes in. A cool pan gives flat, eggy pucks.
- Pint measuresA pint is 2 cups. Two cups of flour is roughly 8-9 oz depending on how it is scooped; the batter should pour like heavy cream, so hold back a little flour or add a splash more milk if it thickens past that.
- Oven temperatureThe recipe gives no oven direction; the term has to be supplied by the cook. In a modern oven, bake at 425F for about 20 minutes, then drop to 350F for another 10-15 to dry the interiors so they do not collapse.
- The panThe recipe names no vessel; batters of this kind were commonly baked in cast-iron gem pans or deep cups, greased and preheated. A modern popover pan, or a deep muffin tin, works; fill the cups no more than two-thirds.
- Do not open the ovenOpening the door in the first 20 minutes drops the temperature and the steam pressure at once, and the biscuits fall. Judge by colour through the glass.
- Beating and restingBeat until smooth, then let the batter stand 20-30 minutes so the flour hydrates. Batter used straight from the refrigerator is often said to rise less; letting it come to room temperature does no harm.
- Yield and servingAbout 10-12 in a standard muffin tin, or 6 large popovers. Serve hot and hollow, with butter and preserves; they soften as they cool.
The same sort of batter appears across nineteenth-century American cookbooks under a shifting set of names -- popovers, breakfast puffs, Laplanders -- and is close kin to the batter English cooks set under a roasting joint for Yorkshire pudding. Cast-iron gem pans, common in the second half of the century, made it easy to bake such batters in individual cups rather than a single dripping pan. That this entry lists ingredients and nothing else suggests the method was taken as known, the cook needing only the proportions.