Home › Griddle-Cakes › Corn Cakes
Corn Cakes
One pint corn meal, one of sour milk or buttermilk, one egg, one tea-spoon soda, one of salt. A table-spoon of flour or corn starch may be used in place of the egg; bake on a griddle.
A two-ingredient batter, essentially, and it behaves nothing like a wheat pancake. The absence of flour is the whole character of the thing: these are thin, lacy, crisp-edged cakes that will tear if you rush them.
- The measurementsA pint is 2 cups: about 2 cups (roughly 9 oz) cornmeal to 2 cups buttermilk. Equal volumes of meal and milk give a thick, spoonable batter rather than a freely pouring one; cornmeal drinks liquid as it sits, so expect to thin it with a splash more milk after five minutes.
- Sour milk means acidThe soda has nothing to react with unless the milk is genuinely acidic. Cultured buttermilk from a carton works. Fresh milk soured on the counter is not the same product as 19th-century clabbered raw milk and should not be substituted.
- CornmealUse plain stone-ground yellow or white meal, medium grind, not self-rising cornmeal (which already contains leavening and salt) and not degerminated fine meal, which turns pasty. Masa harina is a different product entirely and will not work here.
- The saltA full teaspoon of salt for 2 cups of meal reads high by modern habit but is correct for an unsweetened cornmeal cake eaten with butter and syrup or alongside meat. Scale back to ¾ teaspoon if that is your preference.
- Egg or starchThe egg is a binder, not a leavener. The tablespoon of flour or cornstarch offered as a substitute does the same job less well; with neither, the cakes will fall apart on the turn.
- Griddle heatMedium; the book gives no temperature, so judge by the pan. Grease it lightly even on a nonstick surface — cornmeal has no gluten to hold the cake together, so it needs to set firmly before it moves. Wait until the top is dull and the edges look dry, then turn once.
- YieldAbout a dozen 4-inch cakes, serving three or four. They are best straight off the griddle; cooled, they go leathery.
Buckeye Cookery (1877, out of Marysville, Ohio) gives a long griddle-cake section because griddle cakes were breakfast across the Midwest, and cornmeal versions were the older and cheaper form — wheat flour cost money, corn was what the farm grew. The pairing of soda with sour milk or buttermilk was the standard household leavening of the period, predating reliable commercial baking powder in many kitchens; the milk pail could commonly be counted on to yield something sour, and the soda turned that surplus into lift.