Home › Shell-Fish › Oyster Pickles
Oyster Pickles
To every quart of liquor add a tea-spoon of black pepper, a pod of red pepper broken in bits, two blades of mace, a tea-spoon salt, two dozen cloves, and half a pint of best vinegar, add the oysters and simmer gently for a few minutes, take out and put in small jars; then boil the pickle, skim it, and pour over them. Keep them in a dark, cool place, and when a jar is opened, use up its contents as quickly as possible. Oysters pickled thus will keep good four or five weeks.
This is a preserving recipe, and it is the preserving that fails rather than the seasoning. The notes below explain the archaic terms and then why the method cannot be reproduced.
- Why it fails: the acid is too weakHalf a pint of vinegar to a quart of oyster liquor, plus the oysters' own moisture, cannot be assumed to bring the pack below the pH 4.6 threshold that inhibits Clostridium botulinum, and nothing in the recipe measures or verifies it. Shellfish are a low-acid food, and no step here brings the whole jar into a known safe range or holds it there.
- Why it fails: no measured processThe jars are filled hot and covered with hot pickle, but there is no stated jar size, no headspace, no seal, and no boiling-water or pressure processing time. "Simmer gently for a few minutes" is not a kill step for a shelf-stable pack, and hot-fill-and-hold cannot be validated without an acidity figure.
- Why it fails: four or five weeks at cellar temperatureA "dark, cool place" in 1877 meant a cellar or pantry, plausibly 50-65F. Raw-harvest oysters carry Vibrio species and, once jarred anaerobically, the pack is the classic setting for botulinum toxin, which is odourless and does not spoil the flavour first. The instruction to use a jar up quickly once opened suggests the keeping was understood to be marginal.
- What to do insteadIf you want pickled oysters, follow a current tested recipe with a specified vinegar strength and refrigerated storage life. Do not adapt the quantities above by guesswork.
- "Liquor"The oysters' own strained juice, not spirits. A quart of it implies a large quantity of shucked oysters.
- Blades of maceWhole strips of the lacy aril from around the nutmeg seed. Two blades is a modest amount, perhaps in the region of a quarter to half a teaspoon of ground mace; whole blades also had the advantage that they could be fished out.
- Pod of red pepperA whole dried cayenne or similar hot chile, broken up seeds and all. Nineteenth-century pods varied wildly in heat; the quantity is not a reliable guide to the finished pungency.
- "Best vinegar"In this period that generally meant a good cider or wine vinegar, sold at strengths that were not standardised and cannot be assumed to match the 5 percent acetic acid we now expect. The vagueness is exactly why the method cannot be salvaged by arithmetic.
Buckeye Cookery and Practical Housekeeping came out of Marysville, Ohio, the revised 1877 edition of a compilation that first appeared in 1876 as the Centennial Buckeye Cook Book, put together from contributions by Methodist churchwomen, and its shell-fish chapter is a reminder of how thoroughly the railroads had reorganised American eating. Oysters from the Chesapeake and the Atlantic coast reached inland Ohio by rail and barrel in enormous quantity through the second half of the century, and pickling was one of the standard ways of stretching a barrel that arrived faster than a household could eat it. Pickled oysters had been a fixture of English and colonial American cookery long before this - recipes of the same shape, with mace, cloves and a red pepper pod, appear across eighteenth-century receipt books - and they were served as a supper dish, a relish, or part of the cold spread at evening parties. The frank admission that they keep only "four or five weeks" is characteristic of the book's practicality, and also a quiet acknowledgment that home preserving of shellfish was understood, even then, to be a short-term proposition.