Home › Preserving › Sweet Pickled Muskmelon
Sweet Pickled Muskmelon
Select hard melons sufficiently ripe to be wellflavored. Cut in slices and remove the rind and seed portion. To each quart of cold water add one fourth a cup of salt; pour this over the prepared melon to cover well and let stand over night. Drain and set to cook in boiling water.
Cook only a few pieces at a time, and remove each the instant it is tender. If cooked longer, the shape will be spoiled. For seven pounds of melon, make a syrup of four pounds of sugar, three cups of vinegar, half a cup of cloves, and a full cup of cinnamon bark in small pieces.
Pour the syrup over the melon and let stand over night, then drain off the syrup and pack the melon in jars; reduce the syrup by boiling, then use to fill the jars.
The pickling and cooking technique here is sound, but the final step — packing hot fruit into jars and topping with boiled syrup, with no processing at all — is open-kettle canning, and it is the reason this recipe should not be followed to the end.
- Why it fails: no processing, low-acid fruitMuskmelon is a low-acid fruit, and the syrup dilutes three cups of vinegar across seven pounds of melon plus four pounds of sugar. Nothing brings the sealed jar to a temperature that would destroy Clostridium botulinum spores, and the sugar-heavy, marginally acid interior is exactly the environment in which they can germinate. A current tested recipe with a measured acid ratio and a specified boiling-water process should be used instead.
- Vinegar strength is unknowableHousehold vinegar of this period was not reliably standardised and could vary in acetic acid strength from jug to jug. There is no way to calculate the finished pH of this pickle from the recipe as printed.
- MuskmelonIn American usage of the period this means cantaloupe or a netted melon of that family, not honeydew. The instruction to select hard melons "sufficiently ripe to be well-flavored" is asking for fruit at the point where flavour has developed but the flesh still resists a thumbnail.
- The salt stageA quarter cup of salt per quart of water gives a brine of roughly 5 to 7 percent depending on the salt used — a firming soak, not a cure. Overnight in that strength draws water out of the flesh so the pieces hold their edges through cooking.
- The hinge, if you take anything from this pageCooking only a few pieces at a time and lifting each one the instant it yields is the whole craft of it. Melon collapses within seconds of becoming tender, and a crowded pot drops the water temperature so the pieces stew rather than blanch.
- The spice quantities are whole spice, not groundHalf a cup of cloves and a full cup of cinnamon bark in small pieces would be inedible ground; these are whole spices meant to infuse the syrup. The recipe does not say whether they were bagged or strained out before the syrup went over the fruit.
- Sugar by weightFour pounds of granulated sugar is about nine cups. The seven pounds of melon most likely means the prepared weight, after rind and seed cavity are gone, though the recipe does not say so outright; on that reading you would need appreciably more whole fruit.
Sweet spiced melon belongs to a large family of American "sweet pickles" — fruit cooked in a sugar-and-vinegar syrup heavy with clove and cinnamon — that stood on the table beside roast meat much as chutney did in Anglo-Indian households. Muskmelon and watermelon rind were favourite subjects because both are cheap, abundant for only a few weeks, and firm enough to survive brining and boiling without turning to pulp; in the case of the rind, using a part of the melon that would otherwise be thrown out was a point of pride in nineteenth-century housekeeping. Books of this kind treated the jar as a container rather than a sterile system: syrup was boiled, poured hot, and trusted. The scientific work that produced measured processing times for boiling-water and pressure canning came later, and it is the main reason recipes from this period read as confident where a modern one would be cautious.