Home › Vinegar, Pickles, and Pickling › Vinegar, Pickles, and Pickling: Cover
Vinegar, Pickles, and Pickling: Cover
To Pickle Onions with Brine. - Cover the onions with cold brine and let stand two weeks or more, or steep in strong brine for one week, then heat the brine and pour it over them scalding hot.
Or pour over them at once strong and hot brine and let stand two or three days. After steeping in brine drain through a colander, freshen in clear water for twenty-four hours, pour off the water and lay them on a dry cloth to drain. Pack them in jars or bottles and cover with spiced pickling liquid boiling hot. Cork tightly and seal.
Or pour over them cold pickling liquid or cold vinegar and seal.
This is a shelf-stable preserving procedure with no measured quantities anywhere in it, and that is exactly where it fails. The notes below explain the terms and then why the method cannot be followed as printed.
- No brine strength is given"strong brine" in household books of this period generally indicates a heavily salted, often near-saturated solution, and period sources commonly describe testing brine by floating an egg or a potato; this recipe offers no test or measure of any kind. Without a stated weight of salt to water, there is no way to know whether the onions are being salted enough to suppress spoilage organisms or merely seasoned.
- No vinegar acidity is givenModern safe pickling depends on 5 percent acetic acid vinegar and a vinegar-to-water ratio that keeps the finished pickle at pH 4.6 or below. Turn-of-the-century vinegar was frequently homemade and of unknown, often much lower, strength, and the recipe never specifies dilution of the "spiced pickling liquid" at all.
- The freshening step removes the safeguardTwenty-four hours in clear water is meant to draw the salt back out so the onions are palatable. That deliberately strips away the one preservative the process had established, leaving low-acid vegetables to depend entirely on an unmeasured vinegar.
- Onions are a low-acid vegetable in a sealed anaerobic jarCorked and sealed jars of insufficiently acidified onions are a textbook environment for Clostridium botulinum, which grows without oxygen and produces no smell or gas you can rely on. Whole onions are also dense enough that acid penetrates the interior slowly.
- The cold-fill option has no heat step at allThe final alternative, pouring over cold pickling liquid or cold vinegar and sealing, involves no scalding of the onions, no heating of the liquid, and no processing of the closed jar. Nothing in that sequence is capable of destroying spoilage organisms or setting a reliable seal.
- "Cork tightly and seal"Sealing at this date most likely meant a cork driven home and covered over with wax, resin or a bladder cover, though the book does not specify here. That is a closure, not a heat process, and it is the opposite of what a modern water-bath tested pickle recipe does. A cork also does not vent reliably, so pressure from fermentation may build rather than showing itself.
- What to do insteadUse a current tested recipe for pickled onions from a food-preservation authority, with weighed salt, 5 percent vinegar, a stated ratio and a water-bath time. Refrigerator pickles, eaten within weeks, are the low-risk route for this dish.
Salt-then-vinegar is often said to be among the oldest logics of vegetable pickling: the brine draws out water so the vegetable will not dilute the vinegar it is later stored in. The recipe offers three different brining schedules and treats them as interchangeable. Pickled onions were a staple of the British and American cold table through the nineteenth century, served with bread and cheese, cold meat and boiled beef, and small silverskin or button onions were grown specifically for the purpose. Household Discoveries belongs to a genre of compendium published for households that still put up their own vinegar, and its instructions read as reminders to a cook who already knew how strong her brine should be rather than as a formula for a stranger. The vagueness is not carelessness so much as an assumption of shared kitchen knowledge, and it is precisely that assumption which makes the page unusable now.