Home › Cookery › Fried Oysters (Take each oyster separately)
Fried Oysters (Take each oyster separately)
Take each oyster separately and put salt and pepper on them; then roll them in equal portions of meal and flour. Fry them in hot lard until a light brown-Mrs. D.
A three-line recipe that assumes a barrel of shucked Chesapeake oysters and a kettle of rendered lard on the stove. The gaps worth filling are the meal, the fat temperature, and how briefly the oysters should stay in it.
- The hinge: fry fastAn oyster is done when the coating is light brown, roughly 1 1/2 to 2 minutes in properly hot fat. Any longer and the oyster contracts into rubber and weeps liquid that softens the crust from within.
- "Meal" means cornmealIn a Virginia book of this period, meal without qualification almost always means cornmeal; a fine or medium grind works best here. Equal parts cornmeal and all-purpose flour gives the crunch of the one and the adhesion of the other.
- Fat temperatureThe original says only "hot lard." Aim for 365-375F. Below that the coating absorbs fat; above it the crust colors before the oyster heats through.
- Dry the oysters firstDrain shucked oysters and blot them well before seasoning. Standing liquor turns the meal-and-flour mixture into paste on contact and it will slide off in the fat.
- Lard and its substitutesLard was the ordinary frying fat here and still fries beautifully at these temperatures. Peanut oil or a neutral high-smoke-point oil behaves the same way if lard is not to hand.
- Season the oysters, not the flourThe instruction to salt and pepper each oyster separately is deliberate and worth following. Oysters are already saline, and seasoning the dredge instead tends to overshoot.
- Work in small batchesSix to eight oysters at a time in a household pan. Crowding drops the fat temperature and produces the pale, greasy result the recipe is trying to avoid.
- YieldA pint of shucked oysters, about 20 to 24 medium selects, serves three or four as a first course. Serve immediately, with lemon or a vinegar-and-pepper sauce.
Housekeeping in Old Virginia, compiled by Marion Cabell Tyree and published in 1879, is a collection of contributions from named and initialed Virginia housekeepers, which is why this one closes with "Mrs. D." rather than a byline. Oysters were then a cheap, bulk commodity along the Chesapeake and the tidal rivers, shipped inland by rail in kegs and barrels and eaten in quantities that now read as extravagant; a nineteenth-century Virginia cookbook typically carries a dozen or more oyster recipes in a row, fried, scalloped, stewed, pickled and made into fritters. The cornmeal-and-flour dredge is one of several coatings in circulation at the time, alongside the cracker crumbs that appear in Northern and Southern books alike. Terse recipes like this one were written for cooks who already knew the method and needed only the proportions.