Home › Recipes › Lobster Salad
Lobster Salad
One pint lobster meat, French dressing, mayonnaise dressing, lobster coral, claws, capers, radishes or parsley.
Cut the lobster meat into inch cubes, season with a French dressing, and keep on ice until ready to serve; then mix it with one-half the mayonnaise. Make nests of crisp lettuce leaves. Place one heaped tablespoonful of lobster in each nest with one tablespoonful of mayonnaise on top. Garnish with lobster coral, capers, claws, radishes or parsley.
A composed salad rather than a tossed one, and the method still works exactly as written. Most of what needs translating is vocabulary.
- A pint of lobster meatMeasured by volume, not weight: about 2 cups of picked meat, roughly 10-12 oz. That is the yield of two 1 1/4-lb lobsters, or three if they are small. Buying picked claw-and-knuckle meat is simpler but leaves you without shells for garnish.
- French dressing meant vinaigretteIn 1900s American cookbooks this is oil, vinegar, salt and pepper, whisked or shaken, in the neighbourhood of three parts oil to one of vinegar. It is not the sweet, orange, tomato-based bottled dressing that took the name later in the century.
- The hinge: dress it early, sauce it lateThe vinaigrette goes on while the meat chills, so it seasons through; the mayonnaise goes on only at service, half stirred through and half spooned on top, as the recipe directs. Mayonnaise added early tends to loosen against the moisture in the lobster.
- Coral and clawsCoral is the roe of a female lobster, black-green when raw and turning bright scarlet when cooked. It is sieved or crumbled over the top for colour. The recipe does not say whether 'claws' means the small claws with meat in them or cleaned shells used purely as decoration.
- MayonnaiseA period mayonnaise is raw yolk, oil, vinegar or lemon, and salt. If you make your own and are serving anyone pregnant, elderly or immune-compromised, use pasteurised eggs; otherwise a good jarred mayonnaise thinned with lemon juice is a fair substitute.
- Keeping it cold"Keep on ice" meant ice or the icebox, so refrigerate. Cooked shellfish held in a dressing should not sit out at room temperature for long; assemble the nests just before they go to the table.
- YieldA heaped tablespoon per nest is a first-course portion. A pint of meat is about 32 level tablespoons, so figure roughly 16 to 20 nests as an appetiser, or six generous plates if you build them larger for a lunch.
Lobster salad belongs to the era when American lobster shifted from cheap coastal protein to a hotel-menu luxury, and the shift shows in the presentation: individual lettuce nests, a spoonful of mayonnaise crowning each, coral and claw shells arranged for effect. The two-dressing method here -- vinaigrette to season and penetrate, mayonnaise to bind and finish -- appears in other American cookbooks of the period. Capers and radishes as garnish belong to an aesthetic that valued contrast of colour on a white plate as much as flavour.