Home › Clam and Other Chowders › 1,000 Bowls of Manhattan Chowder
1,000 Bowls of Manhattan Chowder
The Tough Club Clam Chowder has won thousands of votes for Tammany in New York and is still going strong. It is made on this Gargantuan scale: 3,000 SOFT CLAMS 1,500 HARD CLAMS 11/2 BAGS POTATOES I BUSHEL RED ONIONS I BUSHEL CARROTS 12 GALLONS CANNED TOMATOES 12 POUNDS SODA CRACKER DUST 12 POUNDS BACK FAT, RENDERED 14 POUND WHITE PEPPER 1/2 SMALL BAG SALT 25 BUNCHES PARSLEY 12 BOXES THYME 24 LEMONS, WITH GRATED SKINS 2 GALLONS CALIFORNIA SHERRY 2 QUARTS WORCESTERSHIRE
This is a formula rather than a set of instructions: a caterer's ingredient list sized for a political outing, with the method assumed. The useful work for a modern cook is understanding the proportions and dividing them down.
- ScaleAs written this is on the order of a thousand bowls, the figure the title itself gives; with no method stated the finished volume can only be guessed at, perhaps 60-odd gallons. Dividing every quantity by 100 gives about ten servings: roughly 30 soft clams, 15 hard clams, three-quarters of a pound of potatoes, half a pound of red onion, half a pound of carrots, a pint of canned tomatoes, and so on.
- Bushels and bagsA bushel of onions is generally reckoned at 50-57 lb and a bushel of carrots at about 50 lb. Potato "bags" varied, 50 lb and 100 lb sacks both being trade standards, so 1 1/2 bags could be anywhere from about 75 to 150 lb, against roughly 50 lb each of onions and carrots.
- Soft clams and hard clamsSoft clams are steamers (long-necks); hard clams are quahogs, and the large chowder size is what is wanted. The two do different jobs: the softs give sweetness and body, the quahogs give the chew and the strong liquor. Both should be steamed open first and their strained liquor used as the base.
- Cracker dustSoda cracker dust is finely crushed soda crackers (saltines), sold as crumbs for exactly this sort of use. It is the thickener, though 12 lb spread through a batch of this size is a modest hand rather than a heavy one.
- Back fat, renderedRendered pork back fat is lard. Ordinary leaf lard works, though diced salt pork fried out in the pot gives a closer flavour and leaves you the cracklings.
- The clams go in lastWith the quantity of vegetables here the pot needs long simmering, but the clams themselves need only a couple of minutes at the end. Chopped clams held at a simmer for any length of time turn to rubber, and the flavour goes into the broth and stays there.
- Sherry and WorcestershireTwo gallons of sherry and two quarts of Worcestershire against a batch this size is a light hand -- on the order of a teaspoon or so of sherry and under half a teaspoon of Worcestershire per bowl. Add both off the heat so the sherry does not cook away.
- Ambiguous quantities"12 boxes thyme" and "1/2 small bag salt" are trade quantities with no fixed modern equivalent; season the reduced batch by taste.
- LemonTwenty-four lemons with their grated zest is a deliberate feature, not a garnish -- it is what keeps a tomato-and-pork chowder of this size from tasting heavy. Keep the zest in proportion when you scale down.