Home › The Waldorf Kitchen › Providence Garnish
Providence Garnish
This is made of cooked mushrooms, small truffles, quenelles, and rounds of goose's fat livers, also stoned and blanched olives. Put them, when ready, into a sautepan with Madeira sauce, and stir over the fire until thickened.
This is a compound garnish in the classical French manner — a set of prepared items bound in sauce and spooned around a roast or braise, not a dish in itself. Everything here is cooked before it meets the pan, so the only real work is the assembly.
- The hinge: warm, do not boil"Stir over the fire until thickened" means a gentle simmer just long enough for the Madeira sauce to coat. Hard boiling breaks the quenelles and melts the foie gras rounds into the sauce; two or three minutes over medium heat is enough.
- Goose's fat liversThis is foie gras — fattened goose liver, here cooked and cut into rounds. Duck foie gras is the usual substitute now, and a firm terrine or torchon slices more reliably than a raw lobe. Add it last and off direct heat.
- QuenellesPoached dumplings of pounded veal, chicken or fish forcemeat bound with panada and egg. For a garnish they should be small — shaped between two teaspoons — and poached in salted water or stock until just set before they go into the sauce.
- Madeira sauceIn this kitchen that meant demi-glace reduced with Madeira, not wine thickened with flour. A good reduced veal stock finished with a splash of dry Madeira gives the same body; the sauce should already be nearly at coating consistency before the garnish goes in.
- Stoned and blanched olives"Stoned" is pitted. Blanching for a minute in boiling water pulls out the harsh brine so the olives do not fight the Madeira — worth doing even with modern cured olives, which are usually saltier than they look.
- TrufflesSmall whole black truffles were an ordinary luxury on this menu and are not now. Preserved truffle peelings or a few slices of good black truffle carry the aroma; truffle oil does not behave the same way in a hot sauce.
- SautepanA wide shallow pan with straight sides, roomy enough for the pieces to sit in a single layer; the recipe itself says to stir them over the fire until thickened.
- Yield and serviceNo quantities are given, as the garnish was scaled to the joint. As a rough modern estimate, something like a cup of sauce and a dozen assorted pieces might serve four, arranged around a roast fillet, sweetbreads or poultry rather than heaped over them.
Garnishes like this were a formal vocabulary in nineteenth-century restaurant cooking: a named combination of set components that told a cook exactly what to put around a piece of meat, so a menu could say "tournedos à la Providence" and be understood in any professional kitchen. Oscar Tschirky's 1896 book, assembled from his years running the Waldorf's dining rooms, prints dozens of them in exactly this compressed form — a list of parts, a sauce, and one line of method — because they were written for people who already knew how to make quenelles and demi-glace. The particular roster here, foie gras and truffles alongside the humble olive, is characteristic of the grand hotel style of the period, where richness was a matter of listing expensive things in sequence. The name is one of many garnish names drawn from places and dedications whose original reference is no longer traceable with any confidence.