Home › Preserves › Lemon Butter
Lemon Butter
Tea-cup white sugar, three eggs, butter the size of half an egg, beat well together; add juice and grated rind of one large lemon, place in a pan set in a kettle of hot water, stir well until thick. This may be made up in quantity, kept for a long time in bottles or jars, and used as needed for filling tarts, etc.
This is lemon curd under an older name, cooked in an improvised double boiler. The method is sound; only the storage advice needs rethinking.
- TeacupA nineteenth-century tea-cup is smaller than a modern measuring cup — reckon it at about 3/4 cup of sugar, roughly 5 oz. A full cup gives a sweeter, less sharp curd.
- Butter the size of half an eggAbout 1 oz, or 2 tablespoons. Kitchen measures by egg-size were common where scales were not, and they are forgiving here.
- The pan set in a kettle of hot waterThis is a double boiler. Keep the water hot but not boiling and do not let the bowl touch it; direct or fierce heat scrambles the eggs into threads rather than thickening them.
- How thick, and when to stopStir constantly and pull it off when it coats the back of the spoon and holds a line drawn through it, around 170-175F. It sets further as it cools, so a curd that looks correct in the pan will be stiff in the jar.
- Rind before juiceGrate the zest into the sugar and rub it in before adding the juice — the sugar draws out the oils and the flavour is markedly stronger than zest added at the end. Take only the yellow, not the white pith.
- StrainingThe original does not mention it, but pressing the finished curd through a fine sieve removes any set egg white and the coarse rind, giving the smooth texture expected of a tart filling.
- StorageDisregard "kept for a long time in bottles or jars." An egg-and-butter curd is not a shelf-stable preserve: refrigerate it in a covered jar and use within a week or two, or freeze it.
- YieldOne large lemon and three eggs give roughly a cup and a half of curd -- enough to fill a batch of small tarts or a single 8-inch pastry shell.
Lemon butter, lemon cheese and lemon curd are broadly the same preparation under different regional names, all of them describing a thick lemon-and-egg conserve rather than anything dairy in the modern sense; "butter" and "cheese" here signal consistency, the way apple butter does. A pan set in a kettle of hot water was a common household answer to egg cookery, and it is the reason curd made this way holds together instead of curdling.