Home › Breakfast And Tea Cakes › Lucy's Pop-Overs
Lucy's Pop-Overs
Two tea-cups sweet milk, two tea-cups sifted flour, heaped a little, butter size of a walnut, two eggs, and one table-spoon sugar, a little salt; bake in hot gem-pans, filled half full, for twenty minutes , and serve immediately. - Mrs. W. A. James, Marshall,
A plain popover batter — thin as cream, leavened by nothing but steam and a very hot pan. Two details in the original need attention: the vessel and the baking time.
- The hinge: preheat the pans"Hot gem-pans" is the one instruction the recipe insists on. Cast-iron gem pans were generally greased and set in the oven to heat before the batter went in. Batter poured into a cold tin is far less likely to rise into hollow shells.
- TeacupsA teacup in American books of this period is usually reckoned at about 6 fl oz, though a good many writers used it interchangeably with a full cup. Either reading works here so long as the milk and flour stay equal in volume, which gives the thin, pourable batter popovers need.
- Butter size of a walnutAbout one tablespoon, melted and cooled slightly before it goes into the batter.
- "Hot" ovenOven heat -- The recipe specifies only hot pans and gives no oven setting; modern popover practice runs 425-450F, and some bakers start at 450F for the first fifteen minutes and drop to 350F to finish.
- Twenty minutes is shortTwenty minutes may be short -- In deep modern popover pans twenty minutes will raise them but can leave the walls damp, so they slump on cooling; modern practice runs 30-40 minutes depending on pan size, until the shells are deep brown and firm to a tap. In small gem cups filled half full the original time may well suffice. Avoid opening the door during the first two-thirds of the bake.
- Gem pansA modern popover pan, with its deep straight wells, gives the tallest result. A standard muffin tin works; fill the cups half full as directed and expect wider, shorter popovers.
- Resting the batterNot in the original, but letting the mixed batter stand 20-30 minutes at room temperature relaxes the gluten and improves the rise. Beat only until smooth — overworked batter toughens.
- Yield and servingThe quantities make roughly three cups of batter; the number of gems depends entirely on the pan. "Serve immediately" is literal: trapped steam softens the shells within minutes. Pierce each one with a knife tip as it comes out if they must wait at all.
Popovers are generally regarded as an American relative of the batter puddings baked under roasting meat in English kitchens -- Yorkshire pudding cooked in individual cups rather than one dripping-pan. The name is traditionally traced to the batter's habit of popping over the rims of the tins as it rises, though this is folk explanation rather than documented etymology. The word appears in American cookbooks from the later nineteenth century, often alongside "gems," the small quick breads baked in heavy cast-iron gem pans of the sort this recipe calls for. The batter contains no chemical leavening at all: the rise comes entirely from water flashing to steam in a fiercely hot pan. The recipe arrives credited to a named contributor -- Mrs. W. A. James of Marshall -- reflecting the compiled, community-sourced character of these late-century regional collections.