Home › Our Susan's Opinion of a Kitchen › Apple Shortcake
Apple Shortcake
M.
Season apple sauce with butter, sugar, etc.; make a nice shortcake, open and butter it and put the apple sauce in layers. Serve with sweetened cream.
A three-line sketch rather than a formula: the book assumes you already know how to make apple sauce and shortcake, and only tells you how to put them together. The points below fill in the numbers it leaves out.
- "M."The letter is most likely a contributor's initial rather than an instruction; community cookbooks of this period commonly credited donors by initials, name, or town.
- Shortcake means biscuit doughIn an American book of this era a shortcake is a rich baking-powder dough baked as one thick round, not a sponge and not the sweet spongy cups sold today. Roughly 2 cups flour, 1 tablespoon baking powder, 1/2 teaspoon salt, 1/3 cup butter cut in, and about 3/4 cup milk gives the right texture for splitting.
- OvenNo baking instruction is given. A modern equivalent is a hot oven, about 425F for 15 to 20 minutes, until the round is browned and firm at the center; an underbaked cake is pale and doughy and tears instead of splitting.
- "Open and butter it"Split the hot cake horizontally, pulling it apart with a fork rather than cutting it, and butter both cut faces while it steams, so the sauce moistens the crumb without reducing it to paste.
- The apple sauceAbout 2 cups of thick, warm sauce for one 8- or 9-inch cake. Season with 2 tablespoons butter and sugar to taste; the "etc." of the original may cover cinnamon, nutmeg, or a little lemon. Drain or reduce a watery sauce first.
- Sweetened creamHeavy cream with sugar stirred in, poured over at the table, not whipped. If you prefer it whipped, keep it soft; the point is that it runs into the layers.
- Yield and timingOne cake serves six. Assemble at the last moment and serve warm, since the cake goes heavy and sodden if it sits with the sauce in it.
Shortcake in nineteenth-century America was a supper bread as much as a dessert: a rich biscuit dough baked in one round, split, buttered, and filled with whatever fruit the season offered. Strawberry is the version that survived, but apple, peach, raspberry, and stewed dried fruit fillings all appear in household books of the 1870s and 1880s, apple among them because sauce could be made from windfalls or from barreled fruit through the winter. The Home Cook Book (first published in Chicago in the 1870s and reprinted widely, including in Toronto) was compiled from recipes submitted by local housewives, which would account for both the initial at the head of this entry and its brevity: it was written for readers who already had a shortcake in their hands and only wanted to know what someone else did with it.