Home › Candy Making › Maple Sugar Candy
Maple Sugar Candy
Two cupfuls of maple sugar, one cupful of cream or rich milk, one pound of English walnuts chopped, one tablespoonful of butter. Test by dropping into cold water; cut into squares when nearly cool.
A terse nineteenth-century candy formula that assumes you already know how to boil sugar: no temperature, no timing, no pan size. The cold-water test is the whole method.
- The hinge: cook to soft-ballThe hinge: the cold-water test. "Test by dropping into cold water" means dripping a little syrup into a cup of cold water and feeling what it does. The recipe does not say which stage, but a candy meant to be cut into squares as it cools points to soft-ball — a ball that holds together but flattens between the fingers, about 235-240F on a modern thermometer — rather than a hard slab.
- Maple sugarThis means solid cake or granulated maple sugar, still sold by weight; two cupfuls packed is roughly 14-16 oz. Maple syrup is not a substitute measure for measure, since the recipe's water balance already assumes the cream is the only liquid.
- Cream or rich milkPeriod "cream" here is closer to today's heavy or whipping cream; "rich milk" was unhomogenised whole milk with the cream not skimmed off. Heavy cream gives the smoother result and is less prone to scorching.
- Add the butter lateThe tablespoon of butter is best dropped in off the heat once the syrup reaches temperature, along with the nuts. Butter stirred in early only encourages the pan to catch.
- The nuts are a lotA pound of chopped walnuts to two cupfuls of sugar makes something nearer a nut brick than a candy. Half a pound gives a square that still holds together and slices cleanly; use the full pound only if you want the sugar as mortar.
- Beat before pouringThe instruction is missing, but "cut when nearly cool" implies a set, opaque candy. Let the syrup cool undisturbed a few minutes, then stir until it loses its gloss and thickens, and pour at once into a buttered 8-inch square pan.
- CuttingScore into squares while the surface is still warm and yielding. Once fully cold, maple candy fractures rather than cuts.
- YieldRoughly 2 lb of candy. An 8-inch square pan gives about 64 one-inch squares; cut larger if you want nearer three dozen.
Maple sugar, not maple syrup, was the household form for most of the nineteenth century: syrup was boiled down and cooled into hard cakes because sugar kept and travelled where a jug of syrup did not, and the sugaring districts of Vermont, New York and Quebec made it in quantity. Cookbooks of the 1890s and 1900s routinely list it by the cupful as an ordinary sweetener. English walnuts — the thin-shelled Persian walnut, so called to distinguish it from the native American black walnut — were by then widely imported and later grown in California, and their mild flavour suited maple better than the strong black walnut did. The recipe reflects a period enthusiasm for home confectionery, when candy pulls and fudge parties were sociable entertainment and a reliable thermometer was still a luxury, which is why the cold-water test carried the whole instruction.