Buckeye Cookery

Tried and approved: the great American housekeeping bible of 1880.

HomeCake-Making › Fruit Cake (One cup butter one of brown)

Fruit Cake (One cup butter one of brown)

One cup butter, one of brown sugar, half pint molasses, two eggs, cup sour milk, tea-spoon soda, pound of flour, one of currants, one and a half pounds raisins. Flavor to taste. This has been thoroughly tested, and is a great favorite. - Mrs. M. E. Nicely.

For the Modern Kitchen

A plain, molasses-heavy fruit cake of the everyday sort — no brandy, no citron, no eggs to speak of. The book assumes you already know how such a cake is mixed and baked, so the working details have to be filled in.

A Little History

Buckeye Cookery (1877, out of Marysville, Ohio) prints its recipes over the names of the women who supplied them, and Mrs. M. E. Nicely's endorsement — "thoroughly tested, and is a great favorite" — is exactly the currency such community books traded in. Note what this fruit cake lacks: no citron, no candied peel, no wine, no dozen eggs. Those belonged to the wedding-and-Christmas "black cake" tradition inherited from English plum cake, which cost a small fortune in imported goods. This is its thrifty inland cousin, leavened with soda against sour milk and molasses rather than by long beating, sweetened chiefly with what a farm kitchen already had.

← Apple Fruit CakeFruit Cake (Twelve eggs one and a half) →