Home › Food for the Sick › PANADA
PANADA
Take two richest crackers, pour on boiling water, let stand a few minutes, beat up an egg, sweeten to taste, and stir all together; grate in nutmeg and add brandy or wine to suit the invalid. Or, break in a pint bowl toasted bread and pour over boiling water, adding a small lump of butter, two table-spoons wine, brandy or whisky; sweeten to taste and flavor with nutmeg or cinnamon.
Panada belongs to the nineteenth-century sickroom, and this version has one structural problem that cannot be worked around: the egg is stirred into water that has already stood and cooled, then served without further cooking.
- The egg never reaches a safe temperatureBoiling water poured over crackers and left to stand "a few minutes" drops well below the range needed to pasteurize egg, and the beaten egg is added after that. The mixture is then eaten immediately, with no cooking step at any point.
- The intended eater is the wrong eaterThis was written for invalids — precisely the group least able to tolerate a Salmonella exposure. Food served to someone already ill, elderly or convalescing is where undercooked egg does the most damage. Use a current recipe for an egg-thickened invalid drink if one is wanted.
- "Two richest crackers"Period crackers were generally plain, hard rounds much drier than a modern saltine. What "richest" specified here is not certain: it may mean the best quality on hand, though in period usage "rich" often indicated a doughs with more butter or shortening.
- The measurements are not measurements"A pint bowl" of toasted bread, "a small lump of butter", "sweeten to taste" — the recipe assumes a cook standing at a sickbed adjusting by eye. There is no yield beyond a single serving for one person.
- The alcoholTwo tablespoons of spirits into a single bowl, and in the first version an unmeasured pour of brandy or wine "to suit the invalid"; spirits appear routinely in period sickroom cookery, and the quantity would read as a substantial dose today, particularly alongside any medication.
Panada comes through Italian and French from the Latin panis, bread: a sop of bread softened in hot liquid, one of the oldest invalid foods in European cookery and a staple of sickroom manuals long before Buckeye Cookery collected it in 1877. Nineteenth-century "food for the sick" chapters worked from a shared logic — that a patient needed nourishment in the most easily swallowed form possible, that eggs and wine were strengthening, and that spices like nutmeg and cinnamon settled the stomach — and many household books of the era carry a panada, a gruel, a beef tea and a wine whey in close sequence. The alcohol was not a treat but a therapeutic ingredient as the period understood it. The dish survives in altered form wherever bread is soaked in warm milk for someone who cannot face solid food.