Home › The Principles of Cookery › Brown Soup
Brown Soup
Cut into small pieces the following vegetables:--One pound of turnips, the same of carrots, half a pound of celery, and six ounces of onions. Put these into a pan with four ounces of butter, and let them stew, with occasional stirring, till brown. Boil one pint and a half of peas in as much boiling stock or water as will make up the entire quantity to three quarts. Add half a pound of toasted bread, season with black peppercorns, Jamaica pepper, and salt. Boil gently for three or four hours, then rub the soup through a coarse sieve, and return it to the pan. When it boils it is ready for table.
A Victorian purée-style soup that gets its colour and depth entirely from browned root vegetables and toasted bread rather than from meat. The one thing to get right is the browning stage: pale vegetables give a thin, sweet soup with none of the character the name promises.
- Brown the vegetables properlyThe four ounces of butter and the diced roots need a long, patient turn over moderate heat, stirred often, until the edges are genuinely brown. The recipe sets no time, but rushing this is the difference between brown soup and turnip soup.
- Jamaica pepperThis is allspice, the dried berry of Pimenta dioica, not a chilli and not a blend. Six to eight berries in three quarts is plenty; it dominates quickly.
- What the peas areThe pint and a half is a volume measure, and the long boiling suggests dried peas rather than fresh; a pint and a half of split peas is roughly a pound and a half by weight. Modern split peas need no overnight soak, but whole dried peas do.
- Making up the liquidThe instruction is to bring everything to three quarts (about 3.4 litres) total, peas included, using stock or water. A light beef or veal stock suits it; the soup is otherwise meatless.
- Toasted breadHalf a pound of dry toast is a thickener, not a garnish. Use stale bread toasted dark, not burnt, and break it up before adding, or it will sit in a raft on the surface.
- Cooking timeThree to four hours at a bare simmer suits whole dried peas. On a modern hob, 90 minutes to two hours with split peas gets everything soft enough to sieve; stir the base occasionally, as the bread makes it catch.
- SievingA coarse sieve and a wooden spoon were standard; a food mill on the medium plate does the same job in a fraction of the time. A blender gives a smoother, more modern texture but leaves in the celery strings unless you pass it afterwards.
- YieldThree quarts serves ten to twelve as a first course. It thickens considerably on standing and will need loosening with stock when reheated.
Brown soup belongs to the family of thick vegetable purées that filled the soup course in nineteenth-century British households on days when no meat stock was to be spared. The colour comes from browning the vegetables in butter, and the body from dried peas and stale bread, two of the cheapest thickeners in a Victorian larder. "Jamaica pepper" for allspice remained ordinary English usage into the twentieth century, a reminder of how much of the Victorian spice shelf arrived through Caribbean trade.