Home › The Principles of Cookery › Yule Dumplings
Yule Dumplings
Cut two small loaves of bread, made with milk, into slices, and pour over them a sufficient quantity of cold milk to render them soft; having gently pressed the bread, then add to it the following: Two ounces of the small and one ounce of the large raisins, picked and washed, some blanched and finely-bruised or grated bitter almonds, grated lemon-peel, mace, and sugar, a piece of rubbed butter, and two or three eggs. All these ingredients are to be well mixed together with two or three spoonfuls of flour, and formed into a consistent mass of dough, which is to be divided by a spoon into dumplings of the proper size; these are to be plunged into boiling water, and when thoroughly done taken out with a skimming-spoon, and served up with cream sauce poured over them. These dumplings furnish a beautiful supper dish.
The problem here is a single ingredient, and it is not one that can be scaled down into safety.
- Bitter almondsBitter almonds contain amygdalin, which the almond's own enzymes convert to hydrogen cyanide when the kernel is crushed, grated or wetted — exactly what this recipe instructs. The recipe calls for them blanched, but a brief scald to loosen the skins is not enough to reliably destroy the enzyme, and the poison can form in the wet mixture itself.
- No quantity is givenThe recipe says only "some" bitter almonds. A toxic dose depends entirely on how many kernels go in and how finely they are broken down, and boiling, for however long, does not reliably drive off the cyanide from the centre of the mass. There is no way to read a safe amount out of this instruction.
- They are not sold as foodRaw bitter almonds are restricted or banned from retail sale in the United States, the United Kingdom and the EU precisely for this reason. If a modern cook found some, it would be through a channel that has not tested them.
- Substitution is not a fix for this pageVictorian cooks used bitter almonds where a modern one would reach for a few drops of almond extract. Since this recipe gives no quantity for them at all, it offers no basis for a measured swap; if you want bread dumplings of this kind, work from a current recipe rather than adjusting this one.
- Two small loavesThe recipe gives no yield. Two loaves of milk bread makes a large quantity of dough, and the fruit and egg specified — three ounces of raisins and two or three eggs — are modest against that much bread.
A boiled bread-and-milk dumpling, enriched with dried fruit, spice and citrus peel, is close kin to the German Semmelknödel and to the sweet bread puddings that travelled into British cookery through the nineteenth century's steady traffic in German domestic recipes. "Yule" is the old Germanic word for the midwinter feast, surviving in both Old English gēol and Old Norse jól. The method itself is pure thrift dressed up for a holiday — milk loaves softened, pressed, bound with egg and a spoonful of flour, and boiled. Bitter almonds were then a standard flavouring in exactly this sort of dish, sold by grocers alongside sweet almonds and used in small quantities for their intense marzipan note; their gradual disappearance from the domestic pantry over the following century is one of the clearest markers of how far food regulation has reshaped what a home cook can buy.