Home › Cookery › Pickled Oysters
Pickled Oysters
1 gallon oysters. 1 tablespoonful salt. 1 " unground black pepper. 1 " allspice. 6 blades mace. 1 small piece cayenne pepper. Pick oysters out from the juice with a fork; stew until gills are opened well, then lay on flat dishes until cold; put in a jar, and cover with equal parts of stewed juice and vinegar. Let stand two days.--Mrs. R. R. Pickled Oysters.
Take two hundred oysters of largest size, rinse them in their own liquor and put them in a stew-pan. Strain the liquor to them, let them come to a boil, and no more. Take them out of the liquor; have ready one quart or more of pure cider vinegar, with which boil whole pepper, a little salt, mace, cloves, and nutmeg.
When it is cool, pour over the oysters. Before serving add a few raw cranberries and thin slices of lemon.--Mrs. S. T.
Pickled Oysters.
Take one gallon oysters and cook them in their own liquor till nearly done. Then skim out the oysters and add to the liquor one teaspoonful whole black pepper, one teaspoonful all-spice, one teaspoonful mace, a little red pepper and half a pint of strong vinegar.
Let it boil a few minutes and then pour over the oysters. When nearly cool, slice in them a large fresh lemon.--Mrs. Col. A. F.
Three contributors' versions of the same dish, all built on the assumption that a barely cooked shellfish held in diluted vinegar will keep on a pantry shelf. That assumption is the problem, and it cannot be fixed by adjusting the seasoning.
- The acid is not measured, and it is dilutedThe first version covers the oysters with equal parts stewed oyster liquor and vinegar; the third adds half a pint of vinegar to the liquor drawn from a gallon of oysters. Nothing here establishes a pH low enough to preserve a low-acid food, and the oyster liquor actively dilutes what acid there is.
- The oysters are never brought to a safe temperature"Let them come to a boil, and no more" and "stew until gills are opened" are visual cues, not thermal ones. Oysters intended to be eaten need to reach 145F throughout; a pan of shellfish pulled the instant the surface liquid moves will not have done so at the centre of the pile.
- Room-temperature standing is the specific failure"Let stand two days" with no mention of a cold cellar or ice is where the recipe stops being merely old-fashioned. A moist, low-acid, low-oxygen jar of seafood held warm is the textbook setting for Clostridium botulinum type E, which is associated with marine sediments and, unlike most botulinum strains, can grow at refrigerator temperatures as well.
- Raw-oyster pathogens are not addressedVibrio vulnificus and Vibrio parahaemolyticus are killed by proper cooking, not by a brief scald and a vinegar bath. The book's authors had no concept of the organism at all.
- If you want the dishUse a current, tested recipe for pickled or soused oysters, one that specifies a cooking temperature, a measured vinegar strength and refrigerated storage with a stated shelf life.
- Reading the measures"Unground black pepper" means whole peppercorns. A blade of mace is one piece of the lacy aril around a nutmeg; conversions to ground mace vary, on the order of a quarter to half a teaspoon each. Two hundred large oysters is, by commercial counts, roughly a gallon shucked, so Mrs. S. T. was cooking for a crowd or for a larder.
- The garnishRaw cranberries and thin lemon slices are decorative and mildly acidic, added at the table. They contribute nothing to preservation and should not be read as doing so.
Housekeeping in Old Virginia (1879), compiled by Marion Cabell Tyree from contributions by Virginia housewives identified by their initials, catches the Chesapeake oyster at the height of its commercial life. Oysters were then among the cheapest proteins in the eastern United States, dredged by the boatload and shipped inland by rail in kegs and cans; pickling in spiced vinegar was one of the standard ways of stretching a glut past the few days a shucked oyster would otherwise last. The spice list here, whole pepper with allspice, mace, cloves and nutmeg, closely resembles the warm, sweet-spiced pickling blend that English cooks had used for soused fish since the seventeenth century, though the resemblance is not by itself proof of how it reached Virginia kitchens. That three separate contributors sent in versions of the same dish tells you how ordinary it was on a Virginia sideboard.