Home › Cookery › Terrapin Salad
Terrapin Salad
Boil them until the shells will come off easily and the nails pull out; then cut into small pieces and carefully remove the sand-bag and gall. To three good sized terrapins, take six hard-boiled eggs; remove the yolks and rub into a powder with half a pound sweet butter. When creamy and light, add one teaspoonful flour. Put this with the meat into a saucepan; season with cayenne pepper and salt, and let it boil for one or two minutes. Just before taking from the fire, add wine to taste and if desired a little mace. Be careful to remove the skin from the legs.--Mrs. A. M. D.
This dish depends entirely on an animal that can no longer be taken or bought in most of the United States, and the preparation as written involves steps that no longer have any legal or practical route.
- The terrapin itselfThe diamondback terrapin (Malaclemys terrapin) is the animal meant here. It is protected to varying degrees throughout its Atlantic and Gulf range, commercial harvest is prohibited in most states, and it is listed on CITES Appendix II. There is no straightforward lawful route to the three live terrapins this recipe begins with.
- Slaughter and butcheryThe recipe does not say the terrapins go into the pot alive, though that was the contemporary practice; boiling until the shells loosen and the nails pull out is as much a killing step as a cooking one, and it would not pass any current standard of humane slaughter.
- The sand-bag and gallThe "sand-bag" is the sand-filled portion of the gut; the gall bladder sits against the liver. Both had to be lifted out whole, since a broken gall bladder ruins the meat with bile. The recipe's brevity on this point assumes skill the modern reader has no way to acquire.
- Wild turtle and contaminationBeyond legality, wild freshwater and estuarine turtles are a recognised carriage route for Salmonella, and long-lived brackish-water species accumulate mercury and other contaminants in their tissue. Neither concern was on the table in 1879.
- If you want to cook something from this pageUse a current recipe for a different dish. The egg-yolk-and-butter liaison here is the interesting part of the method, and it belongs to a whole family of documented terrapin and turtle stews you can read about without cooking.
- Reading the quantitiesFor the record, half a pound of butter is two sticks. The recipe says only "wine"; sherry or Madeira is the usual choice in period terrapin cookery, and it goes in just before the pan comes off the fire. The single teaspoon of flour is likely there to steady the yolk-and-butter binding rather than to thicken.
- Why it is called a saladDespite the title, it is served hot from the saucepan and contains no greens; "salad" here appears to mean a rich dressed mixture of meat and egg rather than anything with leaves.
Terrapin was the great luxury of the Chesapeake table for most of the nineteenth century, and Baltimore and Philadelphia cooks built elaborate ritual around it: the egg-yolk-and-butter binding, the finish of sherry or Madeira, the insistence on removing gall, sand-bag and leg skin. Housekeeping in Old Virginia (1879), compiled by Marion Cabell Tyree from contributions by named Virginia housewives, prints several terrapin dishes, and the attribution to "Mrs. A. M. D." is typical of the book's method: recipes gathered from real kitchens and printed with the contributor's initials rather than rewritten into a house voice. The vogue was its own undoing. Demand from hotels and clubs stripped the marshes so thoroughly that by the early twentieth century terrapin had gone from a food fed to enslaved people and watermen, in the traditional account, to a dish priced beyond most tables, and then to a species requiring protection. The recipe survives as a record of that arc rather than as anything to cook.