Home › Cookery › White Egg Muffins
White Egg Muffins
1 pint of flour. Whites of 8 eggs, beaten to a stiff froth. Add enough milk to make it into a thin batter. Put in a little salt. Very nice.--Mrs. C. C. McP.
This is a batter bread leavened entirely by beaten egg white and steam, with no soda, baking powder or yeast. That fact governs everything about how it is mixed and baked.
- The hinge: fold, don't stirThe whites are the only leavening, so they have to be folded into the batter in two or three additions with a light hand. A batter beaten smooth after the whites go in will bake into a dense, damp puck.
- A pint of flourMeasured by volume, a pint is 2 cups, roughly 8 to 9 oz of all-purpose flour. Southern books of this period generally drew on soft winter wheat, and a soft winter-wheat flour gives the tenderest result, but ordinary all-purpose works.
- "Thin batter" is ambiguousThe milk is genuinely unspecified. Bear in mind the eight whites already contribute roughly a cup of liquid, so judge the milk by consistency -- a batter that pours in a steady ribbon rather than dropping in lumps -- and not by a number.
- Eight whitesThe whites of eight modern large eggs come to about 1 cup. Eggs of the period were not graded and likely ran smaller on average, so measuring to a cup is a fair way to approximate the original intent rather than counting shells.
- The pansThe recipe names no pan. In a book of this date "muffins" would most likely mean batter baked in iron gem pans or in muffin rings, not the sweet cupcake-shaped thing. Grease the pans well and heat them before filling; the initial blast of heat is what makes the batter climb.
- OvenThe recipe gives no oven direction. A hot oven, in the region of 425F for about 20 to 25 minutes until well risen and set, suits a batter raised by egg alone. Opening the door early will collapse them, as with popovers.
- Yield and servingRoughly a dozen. They are meant to come to the table straight from the oven with butter; they deflate and toughen within minutes of cooling.
- The eight yolksEight yolks are left over, and it is worth having a use for them ready before you start: custard, a boiled dressing, or a yolk-rich cake.
Housekeeping in Old Virginia, compiled by Marion Cabell Tyree and published in 1878, gathered short contributions from named and initialed Virginia housewives, which is why this one carries the tag "Mrs. C. C. McP." rather than an author's byline. The recipe belongs to the family of Southern batter breads raised largely by egg, alongside popovers and the spoon and batter breads of the tidewater; chemical leavening was widely available by 1878, but egg-risen breads continued to appear in books of this kind. The recipe does not explain why only whites are used; the result would be a notably pale, light bread, which is all the name is describing. The terse praise at the end, "Very nice," is in keeping with the book's style: these were notes passed between cooks who already knew what a muffin batter should look like.