Home › Vegetables › Sweet Pickled Cucumbers (Cannot be used for the pickles)
Sweet Pickled Cucumbers (Cannot be used for the pickles)
cannot be used for the pickles. Now put the cucumbers and onions in glass quart jars. Mix the mustard, pepper and celery seed with the oil; then add, gradually stirring all the while, two quarts of cider vinegar. Pour this over the cucumbers and onions, fasten the jars and in two weeks the pickles will be ready for use and will keep all winter.
What survives here is the tail end of a pickle recipe: the ingredient list and the salting step are missing, and the page begins mid-sentence. That alone makes it unusable, but the method it describes also falls outside current safe-preserving practice.
- The recipe is a fragmentThe quantities of cucumbers, onions, mustard, pepper, celery seed and oil are all on the missing portion of the page, along with whatever preliminary treatment the opening sentence described. Only the two quarts of cider vinegar is given, so the acid-to-vegetable ratio — the single thing that determines whether a pickle is safe — cannot be worked out.
- No heat processingThe jars are simply filled cold, fastened and set aside for two weeks. Current practice for shelf-stable pickles calls for a boiling-water bath of a measured length, with the jar contents brought to temperature throughout. Fastening a lid on a cold jar seals in whatever was on the cucumbers.
- Oil in an unprocessed jarThe oil floats and coats the vegetables, which can shield them from the vinegar and create low-oxygen pockets where the acid does not penetrate. Modern guidance treats untested oil-containing preserves as unsuitable for pantry storage for this reason.
- Unknown vinegar strengthHousehold cider vinegar of this period was not sold to a guaranteed acidity, and its strength could vary from the 5 percent that tested recipes assume today. Diluted further by the cucumbers' own water, the brine may never reach a pH that reliably suppresses spoilage organisms.
- "Will keep all winter"This reflects the period's confidence in the preserving power of vinegar and salt, and in cold storage rather than a heated room. A modern kitchen cupboard is considerably warmer, and these jars would behave differently in it.
- If you want these picklesUse a current tested recipe for bread-and-butter or sweet cucumber pickles from a food-preservation authority, which will specify vinegar strength, headspace and processing time.
Sweet cucumber-and-onion pickles in a mustard-and-celery-seed brine are close kin to what Americans now call bread-and-butter pickles, a name that only became common in the twentieth century. Cucumbers came in by the bushel in late summer, and pickling was routine seasonal work in households that put up food against a winter without fresh vegetables. The surviving opening phrase, "cannot be used for the pickles," refers to something discarded in the missing step — possibly a drawn-off salting liquid, though the page does not say. The confidence that a sealed jar of vinegar would simply keep reflects a period before the bacteriology of home canning was understood; safe-canning guidance built on measured acidity and timed heat processing is largely a development of the twentieth century, worked out in part by agricultural extension services.