Home › Breads, Rolls, Muffins, Etc. › Coffee Cake (C flour t baking powder Pinch)
Coffee Cake (C flour t baking powder Pinch)
1¾ C flour 1½ t baking powder Pinch salt 3/4 C sweet milk 12 C sugar Sprinkle sugar and cinnamon over top and bake in warm thirty minutes.
A plain sugar-and-cinnamon coffee cake of the kind that filled church cookbooks, written in the shorthand of a cook who already knew the method. Several figures and at least one step did not survive into print, so read it as a skeleton rather than a formula.
- Ambiguous amountThe flour reads 1¾ C, which was checked against the printed page. The sugar is still printed as "12 C," which is not a plausible quantity against 3/4 cup of milk; it is most likely a fraction that lost its marks, and about 1/2 cup would suit the liquid. Treat that number as unreliable rather than measuring it as printed.
- Sweet milkMeans fresh unsoured milk, as opposed to the buttermilk or clabber that would call for soda instead of baking powder. Whole milk is the direct equivalent.
- No fat or egg is listedA cake of this style normally carries a few tablespoons of butter and an egg, and the printed ingredient list has neither. Without them the batter bakes to something closer to a sweet biscuit than a coffee cake.
- "Warm" ovenPeriod recipes more usually say slow, moderate or quick, covering roughly 300F to 450F; "warm" is not one of the standard terms and it is not clear what the contributor meant by it. For a shallow milk batter baked thirty minutes, a moderate oven of about 350F is a reasonable guess rather than a translation.
- ToppingThe sugar and cinnamon go on before baking, not after, so the sugar melts into a thin crust. Roughly 2 tablespoons sugar to 1 teaspoon cinnamon covers an eight-inch pan.
- Pan and yieldNo pan is named. An eight-inch square or a nine-inch round tin, greased, would suit a thirty-minute bake, though with the flour and sugar amounts in doubt any estimate of yield is guesswork.
- Test rather than trust the clockGiven the missing quantities, judge by a clean tester in the center and edges just pulling from the tin instead of the stated half hour.
Coffee cake in American community cookbooks has nothing to do with coffee in the batter; it is the cake served alongside coffee, a category generally credited to German and Scandinavian settlers and a common offering at church socials and morning meetings in the Midwest. Recipes like this one, leavened with baking powder rather than yeast, represent the quick end of that tradition: no rising time, no kneading, on the table in well under an hour. Community cookbooks were often compiled from handwritten cards submitted by members, which would account for instructions that assume knowledge the contributor never thought to write down.