Home › Hen Fruit, or X › Pickled Eggs
Pickled Eggs
2 BAY LEAVES 1/2 TEASPOON ALLSPICE I TEASPOON SALT 2 TABLESPOONS SUGAR Boil eggs 45 minutes, then drop into cold water. When cold, shell and put in a deep bowl.
Wash and boil beets. When tender, pare, slice and add to eggs. Boil vinegar, water, bay leaves, etc. Pour this while hot over the whole eggs and sliced beets. Stand in cold place 24 hours before going to work on them.
Pickled eggs make perfect snacks in camps and cabins too far from the source of supply to keep fresh hen fruit. They're fine to mix with salads or chop into the hash.
A camp-cookery pickle of the mid-century type, written for people keeping food in cabins without refrigeration. As printed it cannot be followed safely, and the reasons are worth understanding.
- No acid ratio is givenThe method calls for boiling "vinegar, water, bay leaves, etc.", but the printed ingredient list appears to begin mid-list and no quantities of vinegar or water survive in the text as we have it. Pickled eggs are preserved chiefly by the acidity of the brine, and without a stated ratio there is no way to judge whether the finished pickle is acidic enough.
- Why that matters hereWhole shelled eggs are dense and low in acid; brine penetrates them slowly, so the centre of an egg can remain near-neutral for days even in a sharp pickle. Under-acidified eggs held in a sealed jar at room temperature are a documented vehicle for Clostridium botulinum, which grows without oxygen and produces toxin that no amount of chilling reverses.
- "Cold place" is not refrigerationA cellar, spring house or shaded cabin shelf runs well above 40F for much of the year. The recipe's whole premise is keeping eggs where fresh ones will not last, which is exactly the storage condition that makes an unmeasured pickle dangerous. A current, tested recipe with a specified vinegar strength and refrigerated storage should be used instead.
- Beets add a further problemSliced cooked beets are low in acid and raise the pH of the brine as they sit, diluting whatever acidity the vinegar supplied. Beet-pickled eggs need more acid than plain ones, not less.
- "Hen fruit"Period slang for eggs, current in American vernacular writing of the era and turning up in camp and sporting cookery. It appears here in the body of the recipe.
- Forty-five minutes of boilingEven setting the preservation question aside, this is roughly four times what a hen's egg needs. The result is a rubbery white and a grey-green ring of iron sulphide around the yolk. Nothing in the pickle requires so long a boil.
Pickled eggs belong to the older logic of the farmhouse and the camp: hens lay heavily in spring and slacken in winter, so surplus was put down in vinegar against the lean months, as cucumbers, beans and pigs' feet were. The beet version, which stains the whites deep magenta and the yolks pink at the edge, is closely associated with Pennsylvania Dutch cookery. Outdoor and sporting cookbooks of this era carried such recipes because they addressed a real constraint -- a hunting cabin or fishing camp "too far from the source of supply" had no ice and no daily deliveries.