Home › Fish and Meat Dishes › Welsh Rabbit
Welsh Rabbit
1 tbsp. flour, 1 tbsp. butter, heaping cup of finely cut cheese, 1/2 cup of milk, 1 egg. Salt and pepper to taste. Serve on saltines.
— Mrs. N. A. Nixon
A terse church-cookbook version of Welsh rabbit that assumes the cook already knows the method: make a thin white sauce, melt cheese into it off high heat, finish with egg. The proportions work, but the order matters more than the list suggests.
- The hinge: low heatCheese sauce breaks when it gets hot enough to boil, leaving stringy curds in a pool of oil. Melt the cheese into the warm sauce over the lowest possible heat, or in a double boiler, and stop stirring once it is smooth.
- Method the recipe omitsCook the butter and flour together for a minute, whisk in the milk, and let it thicken. Then pull the pan off the heat and add the cheese a handful at a time. The egg goes in last, beaten and tempered with a spoonful of the hot sauce before it joins the pan.
- The eggIt thickens and enriches but will scramble at a hard simmer. Once it is in, keep the pan below 180F and serve promptly; the sauce should still be hot enough (about 160F) to cook the egg through.
- "Finely cut cheese"A heaping cup is roughly 4 oz of a firm cheese such as cheddar; grate or dice it small so it melts before the sauce overheats. Pre-shredded cheese is dusted with anti-caking starch and melts grainy.
- Seasoning"Salt and pepper to taste" is thin for this dish. Many period versions of the same sauce carry dry mustard, cayenne or Worcestershire, and a scant quarter-teaspoon of mustard powder lifts it considerably.
- No beer hereMany Welsh rabbit recipes use ale as the liquid. This one is a milk version, common in American community cookbooks of the period.
- SaltinesThen as now, plain soda crackers. Toast them briefly in a dry oven so they do not go soft under the sauce; buttered toast works equally well.
- YieldServes two as a light supper or four as a savory over crackers. It does not hold or reheat well, so make it at the moment of serving.
Welsh rabbit contains no rabbit, and the name is generally traced to English mockery: a cheese supper was the poor Welshman's substitute for game. The spelling "rarebit" is a later genteel correction of a joke that had stopped reading as one. By the time this book was compiled, the dish had become a staple of American chafing-dish suppers and church socials — quick, meatless, made from pantry goods, and easy to produce for a crowd — which explains why a contributor's recipe could be reduced to a bare list of five ingredients with no method at all.