Home › Bread And Bread Making › Rye Bread
Rye Bread
1 cup scalded milk. 1 cup boiling water. 1 tablespoon lard. 1 tablespoon butter. 1/3 cup brown sugar. 1½ teaspoons salt ¼ yeast cake dissolved in ¼ cup lukewarm water 3 cups flour Rye meal To milk and water add lard, butter, sugar, and salt; when lukewarm, add dissolved yeast cake and flour, beat thoroughly, cover, and let rise until light. Add rye meal until dough is stiff enough to knead; knead thoroughly, let rise, shape in loaves, let rise again, and bake.
The ingredient list as printed here has been mangled in transcription: the milk, water, lard, butter and sugar are called for in the method but their quantities are missing, and the fractions have come through as "14" where the original read "¼". Treat it as a sponge-method rye that needs its proportions reconstructed before you start.
- The missing amountsOnly the salt (1½ teaspoons), the yeast, and the 3 cups of flour survive with numbers attached. Comparable sponge breads of the period run to something on the order of a cup each of scalded milk and water with a tablespoon or two each of fat and sugar, but the original figures for this loaf are simply not on the page. Do not guess and expect the timings below to hold exactly.
- "14 yeast cake" and "14 cup"Both are almost certainly ¼. A quarter of a compressed yeast cake is roughly ½ teaspoon of active dry or instant yeast — a small amount for the volume of dough, and the recipe accordingly works through three separate risings.
- Rye meal is not rye flourRye meal in 1896 meant coarsely ground whole rye, closer to today's pumpernickel or dark rye meal than to light sifted rye flour. Light rye will work but gives a paler, softer, less assertive loaf.
- Add the rye by feel, not by cupThe instruction to add rye "until dough is stiff enough to knead" is the hinge. Rye takes up a great deal of water and forms almost no gluten, so a dough that feels right at first can stiffen as it hydrates. Stop while it is still slightly tacky; more rye than that gives a dense, gummy crumb.
- Kneading a rye doughIt will never become smooth and elastic the way a wheat dough does — the stickiness is pentosans, not underdevelopment. Eight to ten minutes with a lightly oiled bench scraper is plenty; flouring the board heavily only drives in more rye.
- Oven temperatureThe original says only "bake." A 1½ to 2 lb rye loaf wants a hot start and a moderate finish: 425F for the first 10 to 15 minutes, then 375F for another 30 to 35, until the internal temperature reaches 200 to 205F. Rye reads as underbaked to the touch long after it is done, so use a thermometer.
- Rising times"Let rise until light" for the sponge means roughly doubled and visibly bubbled — 1 to 1½ hours in a warm kitchen. The shaped loaves need only about three-quarters proof; a fully proofed rye tends to collapse in the oven.
- Yield and slicingThe three cups of wheat flour plus rye make two small loaves or one large one. Let it cool completely, ideally several hours, before cutting — rye crumb sets as it cools and a warm loaf slices into paste.
Rye was New England's second bread grain, and for much of the colonial and early national period the region's everyday loaf was "rye and Injun" — rye meal stretched with cornmeal, steamed or baked long and slow, because wheat was scarce and expensive north of the mid-Atlantic. By the time Fannie Farmer was teaching at the Boston Cooking School in the 1890s, cheap roller-milled wheat flour from the Midwest had reversed that: white bread was the default, and rye had become a flavoring rather than a staple. That shift is visible in the recipe itself, which builds a conventional white sponge with milk, sugar and fat first and only then works rye meal in — a wheat loaf tinted with rye, not the old subsistence bread. The method also reflects the growing availability of reliable compressed yeast cakes from the later nineteenth century, which let a cook use a measured quarter-cake instead of keeping a homemade leaven alive on the shelf.