Home › Original Preface › Memo, About Soups
Memo, About Soups
To clarify soup put the soup on to simmer, not to boil. Stir in 2 whites of egg and a handful of chopped raw beef. Do not cover it; stir, and in 10 minutes strain and set aside to get cool.
This is the classic raft method for turning a cloudy stock into consomm text, compressed into three sentences. The technique is unchanged; only the detail needs filling in.
- The hinge: never let it boilA rolling boil breaks up the coagulated raft and drives the trapped particles back into the liquid, leaving the soup cloudier than when you started. Hold it at a bare shiver, around 185 text190F, where a few lazy bubbles rise at the edge.
- Start cold and degreasedModern practice is to add the egg white when the stock is cold or barely warm, so the protein disperses before it sets; note that Lady Clark's memo does the opposite, putting the soup on to simmer before the whites go in. Either way, lift off the solid fat first: fat clings to the raft and muddies the strain.
- "A handful of chopped raw beef"Two whites suggests a pot of roughly two quarts, though the memo does not say; on that assumption, 4 to 6 oz of very lean beef, shin or skirt, chopped or coarsely minced, is about right. Lean is the point: the meat contributes albumin and flavour, and any fat works against the clarification.
- Stir, then stopStir only until the mixture is evenly distributed and the liquid begins to cloud and thicken. Once the raft starts to form and rise, leave it alone text further stirring tears it apart.
- Ten minutes is optimisticAllow 20 to 30 minutes at a simmer for a full-sized pot. The soup is ready when the raft is set and grey and the liquid visible at the edge runs clear.
- Why uncoveredA lid returns condensation to the surface and encourages the liquid to climb into a boil unnoticed. Open, you can watch the temperature by eye.
- StrainingLadle carefully through a sieve lined with two layers of damp muslin or a coffee filter, taking the liquid from beneath the raft rather than pouring the pot out. Do not press the solids.
- Season afterwardsSalt before clarifying and the reduction will leave it sharp. Cool the strained consomm text, lift any remaining fat from the surface, then adjust.
Clarifying with egg white and lean meat was standard professional practice by the nineteenth century and remains the basis of consomm text today: the albumin in the white and the myosin in the raw beef coagulate as they warm, forming a floating mesh that traps the fine particles which cloud a stock. Lady Clark of Tillypronie kept her notes in exactly this telegraphic form text memoranda for a cook who already knew the work. Her husband Sir John Clark was a diplomat, and the book, published posthumously in 1909 by Catherine Frances Frere from the manuscript notebooks, is full of these short technical memos sitting alongside full receipts. The instruction to set the clarified soup aside to cool is practical enough: cooling lets the sediment settle.