Home › Pastry › Peach Pie (Bake in two separate tins)
Peach Pie (Bake in two separate tins)
Bake in two separate tins an under and upper crust in a quick oven fifteen minutes; when done place in the lower crust one quart peaches prepared by slicing, and adding three table-spoons each of sugar and cream, cover with the top crust, and place in oven for five minutes. Treat strawberries, raspberries, etc., in the same way. -Mrs. F. L. T., New Orleans.
This is not a baked pie so much as an assembled one: both crusts are baked empty, then filled with raw sweetened fruit and given five minutes to warm through. A few notes make the method work as intended.
- The hinge: the crusts must be fully bakedNothing after assembly cooks the pastry — five minutes only warms the fruit. Bake both rounds until they are properly browned and dry underneath, not merely set.
- "A quick oven"Commonly glossed as somewhere around 400-450F, though period usage of the term varied. Fifteen minutes at that heat will brown a rolled crust; check at twelve.
- Baking the shells flatDock the pastry all over with a fork and weight the bottom crust with beans or pie weights so it does not dome. The top crust can be baked on the back of a second tin or on a flat sheet to keep it in a shallow dish shape.
- Tin size and yieldA quart of sliced peaches suits a 9-inch tin and gives about six servings. A quart of slices is roughly a pound and a half of fruit, or four to five medium peaches.
- Three tablespoons of sugar is restrainedIt assumes ripe late-summer fruit. Taste the sliced peaches and adjust; underripe supermarket stone fruit will want more, plus a squeeze of lemon.
- The creamThe recipe says only "cream". Three tablespoons is a gloss, not a filling, stirred through the slices. It will loosen as the fruit gives up juice, so mix it in at the last moment.
- Serve at onceThere is no thickener and no set. Left standing, the juice soaks the base and the pie collapses. Assemble, warm, cut, serve.
- Other fruitStrawberries and raspberries behave as the note says, but they weep faster than peaches; sugar them separately, drain briefly, then fill.
The two-tin method belongs to a family of nineteenth-century American desserts that sit between pie and shortcake — the crusts baked dry and separately, the fruit added raw so it keeps its color and perfume. It was a sensible answer to a wood-fired range, where a filled double-crust pie meant a long, uncertain bake and a sodden bottom, and it flatters fruit at the peak of ripeness in a way a long bake cannot. Recipes of this kind often carry initialed attributions; "Mrs. F. L. T., New Orleans" is typical of the community-cookbook practice of crediting the contributor while keeping her name half-private. Peaches were the obvious summer fruit for such a book — the Gulf and Piedmont South grew them heavily, and by the late nineteenth century rail shipment was making the crop a commercial as well as a dooryard one.