No. 1750

Shoulder of Lamb a la Garnier

Epaule d'Agneau a la Garnier

After boning two shoulders of lamb, leaving on only the end or handle bones, stuff the insides with lamb forcemeat (No. 92); braise them the same as for a la Benton (No. 1748); then drain, skim, and reduce the stock with an equal quantity of espagnole sauce (No. 414). Dress and glaze the shoulders, then garnish around with whole chestnuts (No. 654); braised celery (No. 2721); cover the garnishing with a part of the sauce and serve what remains separately.

← No. 1749 Shoulder of Lamb, a la Dessaix Lamb No. 1751 Shoulder of Lamb with Cucumbers →

For the Modern Kitchen

This is a cross-referenced entry from a professional kitchen manual: almost every component sits elsewhere in the book, so the work is mostly in the parts Ranhofer does not restate. Read it as an assembly plan rather than a recipe.

What you actually have to makeFour separate preparations are hidden in the numbers: a lamb forcemeat, a braise, espagnole sauce, and two garnishes (whole chestnuts, braised celery). Espagnole is a brown roux sauce built on veal stock; a good reduced brown stock or demi-glace stands in without damage to the dish.
Boning the shoulderLeave the shank bone in as directed — it holds the shape and gives the carver something to grip. Ask a butcher for two shoulders tunnel-boned with the shank attached; expect roughly 4 to 5 lb bone-in each, though weights vary.
ForcemeatRanhofer's forcemeats of this type are generally lean meat pounded with a panada and fat, in effect a fine sausage stuffing. Keep it cold, season it firmly, and do not overfill: it expands as it sets and will split the seams. Sew or truss the shoulders closed and tie them.
The braiseBrown the tied shoulders, set them on a bed of aromatics with stock roughly halfway up, cover, and cook at 325F for 2 to 2.5 hours until a skewer slides in with no resistance. This is a collagen cut; pink is not the goal here.
Reducing and glazingStrain the braising liquid, skim the fat hard, and reduce it with an equal volume of espagnole until it coats a spoon. Glazing means brushing the shoulders with the thickened, syrupy sauce and returning them to a hot oven or under a broiler briefly until they shine — it is not a sugar glaze.
ChestnutsWhole chestnuts are simmered gently in stock so they stay intact; they collapse into meal if boiled hard. Peeled vacuum-packed or frozen chestnuts are the practical modern option and need only warming through in the sauce.
CeleryBraised celery means trimmed hearts, blanched, then cooked slowly in stock and butter until translucent. Two heads gives enough for a platter of this size.
Yield and serviceTwo stuffed shoulders serve 8 to 10. Serve the meat sliced across the grain on a warm platter, garnish banked around it, part of the sauce spooned over the garnish and the rest in a sauceboat as written.

A Little History

The Epicurean (1894) is Charles Ranhofer's record of some thirty years as chef at Delmonico's in New York, and it is organized like a professional reference rather than a domestic cookbook — hence the chain of numbered cross-references, which let a kitchen brigade assemble a dish from components already in production. The à la Garnier name follows the nineteenth-century French convention of attaching a proper name to a fixed garnish; here chestnuts and braised celery, both cold-weather items, mark it as an autumn or winter service. Boning and stuffing a shoulder was standard high-restaurant practice for a cut too awkward to carve at table, and it turned an inexpensive joint into a centerpiece — the same logic that produced the stuffed, glazed and garnished roasts filling the surrounding pages of the lamb chapter."}