Home › Our Susan's Opinion of a Kitchen › Pickled Oysters
Pickled Oysters
Mrs. C. G. Smith.
Wash them from their liquor and put them into a porce. lain lined kettle, with strong salt and water to cover them; let them come to a boil, and then skim them into cold water; scald whole peppers, mace, and cloves in a little vinegar; the quantity of these must be determined by the number of oysters; when the oysters are cold, put them into a stone jar with layers of spice between them, and make liquor enough to cover them from the liquor in which they were cooked; spice your vinegar and cold water to taste.
This is a room-temperature preserve of a low-acid shellfish with no measured acid, no measured salt and no stated storage conditions. It cannot be made safely as written, and the points below explain where it breaks down rather than how to fix it.
- The acidity is undefinedThe instruction is to "spice your vinegar and cold water to taste," with the covering liquor further diluted by the salty cooking water. Nothing here fixes the pH of the finished jar, and pickled seafood needs a reliably acid brine to be shelf-stable rather than one judged by flavour.
- Low-acid seafood at ambient temperatureOysters held in a stone jar under a diluted, unmeasured brine are the classic setting for Clostridium botulinum, which grows without oxygen and produces toxin that no amount of chilling or rinsing removes. The brief boil kills spoilage organisms but not spores.
- No storage instruction at allThe recipe ends with the jar filled. A stone jar of this kind would ordinarily have been kept in a larder or cellar rather than chilled; there is no direction to refrigerate and no shelf life given, so the reader has no way to know when the jar has passed.
- Vinegar strength has changedHousehold vinegar of this period varied widely in strength and was often homemade, so "vinegar" carries no fixed acetic acid content. Modern 5% vinegar and a period barrel vinegar are not interchangeable quantities, which makes the original proportions impossible to reconstruct honestly.
- "The quantity must be determined by the number of oysters"The spice, the salt and the covering liquor are all left to the cook's judgement. That is workable in a recipe eaten the same day and not workable in a preserve, where the ratios are the safety mechanism.
- Terms in the textA porcelain-lined kettle is an enamelled pan, specified because bare iron or copper reacts with vinegar and salt. Mace is the outer covering of the nutmeg, milder and more floral than the seed. "Wash them from their liquor" means drain off the packing liquid the oysters came in.
- If you want the dishUse a current, tested recipe for pickled or soused oysters from a food-safety authority or a modern seafood cookbook, one that specifies vinegar strength, salt weight and refrigerated shelf life.
Pickled oysters were a staple of the American mid-century table, and they appear in cookbooks of this period. Oysters were then cheap, abundant and shipped inland by the barrel from Chesapeake and New York beds; pickling in spiced vinegar was one of the standard ways to stretch a shipment beyond the few days a barrel of shell oysters would keep. The spice list here — whole pepper, mace, cloves — is the ordinary English pickling mixture carried into American practice, and the stone jar was the default vessel for anything held in vinegar or brine before glass canning jars became cheap. The recipe is characteristic in attributing itself to a particular woman — here only 'Mrs. C. G. Smith' — and trusting her reader to supply proportions from experience, which is exactly what makes the instructions unusable now.