Home › The World's Kitchen › Fresh Beef Tongue, Creole
Fresh Beef Tongue, Creole
Prepare a fresh beef tongue, as per tongue gendarme, and serve it with a Creole sauce instead of the gendarme garnishing.
This is a cross-reference recipe: the whole method lives in the entry for tongue gendarme, and all that changes here is the sauce. That makes the two things worth spelling out the prep it assumes and what a Creole sauce meant to this kitchen.
- What the base method isA fresh (unsalted, uncured) beef tongue is normally soaked, then simmered in water with aromatic vegetables and seasonings until tender; the exact aromatics belong to the tongue gendarme entry, not to this one. Whatever that method is, nothing in the Creole version alters it -- only the sauce changes.
- Simmering timeA whole fresh beef tongue of 3-4 lb needs roughly 3 hours at a bare simmer, never a rolling boil. It is done when a skewer slides into the thickest part with no resistance; undercooked tongue is rubbery and cannot be rescued by sauce.
- The hinge: peel it hotThe thick outer skin must be slit and pulled off the moment the tongue comes out of the pot, while it is too hot to hold comfortably. Let it cool in the skin and the membrane grips, and you will lose meat trying to trim it.
- Fresh, not cornedBeef tongue today is generally sold fresh or frozen; if you are offered a cured or pickled tongue it will be pink and salty and needs a long soak with several water changes before it will suit this treatment.
- Creole sauceIn a book of this vintage that generally means a tomato-based sauce built on onion, green pepper, garlic and often a little ham or stock, seasoned with cayenne and thyme, cooked down until it coats. It should be sharp enough to cut the richness of the meat.
- Slicing and servingCarve on a slight diagonal from the middle of the tongue toward the tip, discarding the gristly root end, and nap the slices with the hot sauce rather than saucing the whole platter. A 3-4 lb tongue yields 6 to 8 portions.
- Cooking liquidThe strained broth is a strong, gelatinous stock. It is worth keeping for the sauce itself or for soup rather than pouring away.
Beef tongue was standard middle-of-the-menu meat in professional American kitchens around 1900, when using the whole animal was ordinary rather than a virtue, and books of this type give it several treatments in the same clipped, cross-referenced style used here. The "gendarme" name attached to the base recipe generally refers to the smoked, stiff, flattened tongue sausage of that name, and the naming in these books is loose. Labelling the variant "Creole" signals the Louisiana-inflected tomato, pepper and cayenne sauce that had by then become a fixture on hotel and restaurant menus far outside New Orleans, used much as a chef today might write "provencale" or "arrabbiata": a shorthand for a whole family of dishes rather than a single fixed formula.