Home › A Calendar of Dinners › July 20
July 20
Menu: Roast Beef's Heart; Boiled New Potatoes; Cauliflower au Gratin; Baked Bean Salad; Cheese Aigrettes; Apricot Meringue Pie; Coffee Cheese Aigrettes-Bring 2 tablespoons Crisco and 1/2 cup water to boiling point, then add 1/2 cup flour and stir until mixture leaves sides of pan. Cool, but do not allow to become cold, then add 2 eggs, 1 Vegetable Soup Fried Fish Baked Shoulder of Mutton Onion Puree by 1, 4 tablespoons grated cheese, July 23 salt, pepper, and paprika to taste and beat well. Allow to stand in cool place 30 minutes. Drop by teaspoons into hot Crisco and fry a golden brown. Drain and sprinkle with grated cheese. Serve hot. The Crisco should not be too hot or the cheese will burn. Vegetarian
This is a choux paste — the same panade used for cream puffs — set up to be seasoned with cheese and deep fried. Note that the text breaks off mid-sentence, so the cheese quantity, seasoning and frying instructions are missing from this page.
- The hinge: dry the panadeThe flour must be stirred over heat until the paste pulls cleanly from the sides of the pan and films the bottom, roughly two to three minutes. An underdried paste will not hold air and the aigrettes collapse in the fat.
- Egg temperature"Cool, but do not allow to become cold" is the point: the paste should be warm rather than hot, around 140F/60C. Too hot and the eggs may scramble into the paste; cold and they will not blend in smoothly.
- CriscoCrisco in 1913 was a hydrogenated cottonseed shortening. Any solid vegetable shortening works here; unsalted butter also makes a good panade, though it browns faster in the pan.
- What is missingComparable cheese aigrette recipes add dry grated cheese — Parmesan or a sharp aged Cheddar — with salt and cayenne, sometimes mustard, beaten in after the eggs. The amounts for this version are lost where the page breaks off; consult a complete choux recipe.
- FryingThe missing instructions would have called for small spoonfuls dropped into deep fat and fried until they stop swelling and are evenly brown. Modern practice puts the fat at roughly 365-375F; cooler fat tends to make them greasy, hotter fat sets the outsides before the centres cook.
- YieldA half-cup of flour with two eggs would make a few dozen small aigrettes, enough for a savoury course for four to six, served hot as soon as they drain; the truncated text leaves the exact quantities uncertain.
- Section headingThe page carries the heading "Coffee", which does not correspond to the recipe printed on it; the aigrettes are not a coffee preparation.
Aigrette is French for a tuft or spray of feathers, and the name is usually explained by the feathery points the paste throws out in hot fat — a traditional explanation rather than a documented one. English and American cookbooks of the late nineteenth century placed cheese aigrettes among the savouries — the small, salty course served after the sweet in the Anglo-French dinner sequence, alongside cheese straws and anchovy toasts. The Story of Crisco (published by Procter & Gamble in 1913, with recipes credited to Marion Harris Neil) set out to show that a new hydrogenated vegetable shortening could stand in for butter and lard in every branch of cookery, and a choux paste, which depends on fat and water combining with flour, was a useful thing to demonstrate.
What survives here is the working half of a fried cheese fritter: bind, chill, drop by spoonfuls into hot fat, drain. The quantities that came before it are not recoverable, so treat the method rather than the measures as the usable part.
- Crisco means shorteningCrisco was hydrogenated vegetable shortening, sold from 1911 as a frying fat with a high smoke point and no meat flavour. Any neutral frying oil or solid vegetable shortening behaves the same way in this recipe.
- The temperature warning is the hingeThe closing line is the important instruction: cheese scorches at a lower temperature than most batters need in order to brown, so the fat must be kept moderate rather than at a normal deep-frying heat. The recipe itself gives no figure; judging the fat by eye and keeping it well short of smoking is what is being asked for.
- Why the 30 minutes mattersChilling firms the fat in the cheese and lets any starch in the binder hydrate, so the spoonfuls are more likely to hold their shape instead of dissolving into the fat.
- Dropping by teaspoonsA teaspoon of mixture gives a fritter roughly the size of a walnut. Larger spoonfuls brown outside before the centre is hot.
- Depth and batchingThe fat needs to be deep enough for the fritters to float clear of the pan bottom. Fry six or eight at a time at most; a crowded pan drops the fat temperature and the fritters absorb it.
- Draining and finishingDrain on paper or a rack, not on a plate, or the undersides steam. The final dusting of grated cheese is added off the heat and relies on residual warmth, so serve immediately.
- SeasoningPaprika here is the sweet Hungarian or Spanish sort used for colour and mild warmth, not a hot chilli powder. Salt with restraint until you know how salty the cheese is.
The Story of Crisco (1913) was published by Procter and Gamble to teach American cooks what to do with a fat that had no culinary tradition behind it. Hydrogenated cottonseed oil arrived in 1911 as a solid, shelf-stable, flavourless substitute for lard and butter, and the book's argument is made largely through recipes: it is full of frying, because frying was where the new fat's high smoke point and neutral taste told most clearly against the smoke and pork flavour of lard. "Calendar of Dinners" — the title under which Procter and Gamble issued its menu-and-recipe material, and the source of this entry — assigns menus to each day of the year, a common device in period cookbooks aimed at the middle-class housekeeper planning without a cook. Small fried cheese balls of this kind appear as entremets and savoury-course fare in Anglo-American cookery of the period, generally bound with egg and a little flour or breadcrumb and served hot as a garnish or a light course.