Home › The Principles of Cookery › Beetroot Soup
Beetroot Soup
Cleanse carefully, boil, and peel two fine beetroots; boil also two onions and mince them together with the beetroot very finely. Take three or four table-spoonfuls of vinegar and one of brown sugar, with rather more than half a gallon of good gravy soup; add this to the mixture of beetroot and onion, and put it into a saucepan to boil, when some small pieces of cold veal or other meat, well covered with flour, may be boiled and served up in it. Probable cost, without gravy, 6d. Time to boil with the soup, until the onions are tender.
A Victorian sweet-sour beet soup built on leftovers: cooked beetroot, cooked onion, and scraps of cold roast meat floured and simmered in stock. The details that need translating are the stock, the volume, and the acid.
- "Good gravy soup"Not gravy in the modern sense but a clear, well-flavoured brown meat broth, usually beef or veal bones with root vegetables. A good unsalted beef stock is the direct substitute; a thin, watery cube broth will leave the soup tasting only of vinegar and sugar.
- The quantity"Rather more than half a gallon" of an imperial gallon is about 2.4 litres, or roughly 10 cups. That plus two beetroots and two onions serves eight generously; halve everything for a household of four.
- Cooking the beetrootBoil the beets unpeeled with the root and an inch of stalk left on, so they do not bleed out into the water. Medium beets take 40 to 60 minutes; the skins slip off under cold water.
- The vinegar is structuralThree or four tablespoons of vinegar against one of brown sugar is a firm sweet-sour balance, and the acid also fixes the colour, which otherwise dulls to brown as the soup sits over heat. Add it as directed rather than at the end, but taste before serving and adjust the sugar.
- Do not boil it longThe instruction to boil "until the onions are tender" is odd, since the onions were already boiled before mincing. Ten to fifteen minutes at a bare simmer is enough to marry the flavours; a long hard boil flattens both the colour and the sweetness of the beet.
- The floured meatCold veal, beef or chicken cut in small dice and tossed in flour thickens the soup slightly as it heats. Give it at least five minutes of simmering so the raw flour taste cooks out, and shake off the excess or the broth turns cloudy and pasty.
- TextureAs written this is a chunky, rustic soup of minced vegetables. A brief pass with a stick blender before the meat goes in gives the smooth crimson purée a modern eater expects, if that is what you want.
- SeasoningThe recipe assumes a well-seasoned stock and calls for no salt or pepper. Season at the end, after the vinegar and sugar are in, since acid and sweetness both change how salty a soup reads.
Cassell's Dictionary of Cookery was a late-Victorian household compendium, and this entry shows a sweet-sour beet soup being fitted to British habits. The vinegar-and-sugar treatment of beetroot with meat broth is the same family as Polish barszcz and Ukrainian borscht, though those are generally traced to a much older soup made from fermented beet or hogweed, and the sour note there came from natural fermentation rather than a bottle of vinegar. Whether the English version owes anything to those soups or arose on its own is not something the entry tells us. What makes it distinctly English is the frame: it is built on "gravy soup," itself a dish of the Victorian kitchen, and finished with scraps of cold veal floured and dropped in or joint into Tuesday's dinner. The costing of sixpence, given without the stock, is a reminder that these books were sold to mistresses and cooks who were expected to account for every dish.