Home › The Principles of Cookery › Eggs, Dished
Eggs, Dished
Take a strong earthen or metal dish. Butter the inside well. Break into it, without damaging the yolks, as many eggs as it will hold without their lying one upon the other. On the top of each drop pepper, salt, and a little bit of butter. Set them into the oven, upon the stove, or in an American oven before the fire; watch their progress, and as soon as the butter is all melted, and the whites well set, serve. The heat of the dish will cook them a little more after they are taken from the oven. Eggs so done are often preferable to fried eggs. They are free from the tough brown under-surface to which the latter are liable, which also is indigestible, even when it is rather crisp than horny.
This is what a modern cook would call shirred or baked eggs. The method is sound as written; only the equipment language and the heat need translating.
- The hinge: pull them earlyThe dish carries enough stored heat to keep cooking the eggs after it leaves the oven, and the recipe says so. Take them out when the whites are just set but still trembling at the edge of the yolk, or you will serve them chalky.
- Oven temperatureCassell's gives none. Around 375F is a useful modern setting for a shallow dish of eggs, roughly 8 to 12 minutes to set the whites without hardening the yolks. At lower temperatures the whites simply take longer and are easier to under-set.
- "A strong earthen or metal dish"Any shallow, heavy, oven-safe vessel: a cast-iron skillet, a gratin dish, small individual ramekins. The recipe's insistence on a strong dish suggests thin or lightweight vessels were thought less reliable.
- "An American oven before the fire"A Victorian tin reflector oven, an open-fronted box set facing the hearth to bounce radiant heat onto the food. Irrelevant now, but it explains the vagueness about temperature — the cook judged by watching, not by dial.
- "Upon the stove"Meaning the hob, with the dish set directly over low heat. This works but scorches the base easily; if you do it, use the lowest flame and cover the pan so the tops set by trapped steam.
- Butter as the timerThe recipe pairs two visual cues: the butter dots fully melted and the whites well set. Both are still usable; distinct pieces of cold butter read more clearly than butter smeared over the surface.
- YieldThe recipe sets no number: fill the dish with as many eggs as fit in a single layer, which is the point of the instruction not to let them lie one upon the other. A shallow pan of ordinary size will take only a few.
- The claim about fried eggsThe browned underside of a fried egg is Maillard reaction, not something indigestible. The preference for baked eggs is a matter of texture rather than health, whatever the period thought about it.
Baked eggs of this kind appear in English and French cookery under a run of names — oeufs sur le plat, oeufs au miroir, shirred eggs. The origin of "shirred" is uncertain; it is often linked to the shallow dish the eggs were cooked in, but that derivation is traditional rather than established. The dig at the "tough brown under-surface" is very much of its moment. Late-Victorian household writing was preoccupied with digestibility, and browned or crisped surfaces were widely suspected of sitting heavily on the stomach — a suspicion that shaped a great deal of invalid and nursery cookery in the period, and which the chemistry of browning has since undone.