Home › The Principles of Cookery › Haddock, Yorkshire Mode of Dressing
Haddock, Yorkshire Mode of Dressing
Take a perfectly fresh haddock, empty and wash it, rub it with a little salt, both inside and out, and hang it in an airy, cool situation for two days. Put it in a saucepan of boiling water, and simmer it gently for ten minutes. Take it up, drain it, remove the head and the skin, dip it in beaten egg, or a little thin flour and water, and strew over it some rather highly-seasoned bread-crumbs. Pour a table-spoonful of clarified butter over the fish, and put it in a Dutch oven before the fire until it is nicely browned. Boil an egg six minutes; pound the yolk, and mix it with a quarter of a pint of good melted butter. Chop the white into small dice, stir them into the sauce, and serve in a tureen. Time, a quarter of an hour to toast. Sufficient for two persons. Probable cost, 9d. or more.
The cooking here is straightforward Victorian work, but the first sentence is the problem: a gutted fresh haddock, rubbed with an unspecified amount of salt, hung at room temperature for two days before it is ever heated. That step cannot be reproduced safely in a modern kitchen, and the rest of the method does not compensate for it.
- The two-day hang is the failure point"An airy, cool situation" in an unheated Victorian larder or scullery might sit near 45-50F in winter; a modern kitchen or pantry does not. Fish held for 48 hours above refrigeration temperature supports rapid growth of spoilage bacteria. Cold-water marine fish also carry Clostridium botulinum type E in the gut and gills, though that organism needs anaerobic conditions and is a greater concern in wrapped or enclosed fish than in one hung in open air.
- "A little salt" is not a cureGenuine light-cured haddock (Finnan and its relatives) relies on a measured brine or dry salt at a known concentration, held at a known temperature, usually followed by cold smoke. A rub of unmeasured salt inside and out is seasoning, not preservation, and gives no reliable barrier to bacterial growth.
- Cooking does not undo itTen minutes' simmering plus browning will kill vegetative bacteria, but it does not reverse spoilage that has already occurred, and heat-stable breakdown products formed during spoilage are not removed by cooking. Nothing later in the recipe undoes what the hang allows.
- Use a current recipeIf you want crumbed haddock with egg sauce, work from a modern recipe that starts with fish kept refrigerated until it is cooked. Skip the hanging entirely rather than trying to shorten or chill it into safety.
- What the old vessels meantFor reading rather than for making: a "Dutch oven" here is the tin reflector oven stood open-side to the fire, doing the work of a grill or broiler, and "a quarter of an hour to toast" refers to that browning stage, not the whole dish.
- "Melted butter" is a sauce, not butterIn nineteenth-century English cookery books melted butter means a flour-thickened butter sauce, roughly the base of what we would call a white sauce. A quarter of a pint is a gill, about 5 fl oz or 150 ml; with the pounded yolk and diced white stirred in, this is the ancestor of modern egg sauce for fish.
Haddock is the fish of the northeast coast, and Yorkshire and the Scottish ports built a family of light cures around it because a landed catch had to travel inland before railways made that quick. Salting and air-drying a haddock for a day or two firmed the flesh, drew out water and gave a faintly cured flavour; the fully developed version of the idea is Finnan haddie, generally traced to the fishing villages of Aberdeenshire and salted and cold-smoked rather than merely hung. The method here dresses a plain boiled fish twice over, first poached, then crumbed and browned before the fire. The costing tells the rest of the story: ninepence or more fed two people, which puts this among the everyday dishes of a modest household.