Home › The Principles of Cookery › Halibut, Stuffed and Baked
Halibut, Stuffed and Baked
Take about three pounds of halibut, clean it well, and fill it with an oyster stuffing (see FORCEMEAT OF OYSTERS). Bind it up securely, lay it in a baking-dish, squeeze the juice of a lemon over it, dot it over with little pieces of butter, and bake in a moderate oven, basting it continually. Drain carefully, and put on a hot dish. Have ready half a pint of brown gravy, boiling hot, pour it over the fish, and serve.
A plain Victorian bake that depends entirely on not overcooking the fish. Halibut is lean and dries out faster than almost any other white fish, and "basting continually" is the original's attempt to fight that.
- The hinge: internal temperaturePull the fish at 130-135F at the thickest point; the residual heat carries it the rest of the way. Halibut cooked to flaking-dry is the usual failure with this dish, and no amount of gravy repairs it.
- "A moderate oven"Around 350F; the Victorian term covers roughly 325-375F. As a modern rule of thumb for a 3 lb piece, reckon about 10 minutes per inch of thickness measured at the deepest part, plus a few extra minutes for the cold stuffing in the cavity.
- Half a pint of gravyCassell's is a British book, so a pint is 20 fl oz and half a pint is 10 fl oz, about 1 1/4 US cups. Brown gravy here means a meat-stock gravy, thickened and well seasoned; the recipe has it poured over the fish just before serving rather than baked with it.
- What cut to buyThree pounds of halibut with a cavity to fill means a middle cut with the bone in, or two thick fillets sandwiched around the stuffing. A whole small halibut is unlikely at a modern counter; ask for a bone-in steak section or use two 1 1/2 lb fillets.
- The oyster forcemeatThe cross-reference sends you to a separate oyster forcemeat recipe, which is not reproduced here; period oyster forcemeats are typically breadcrumb-based, enriched with butter or suet, bound with egg and mixed with oysters. Chop the oysters rather than leaving them whole, or the outside of the fish will be done long before the centre of the stuffing reaches temperature.
- "Bind it up securely"Kitchen twine at 1-inch intervals, or skewers laced with string. Fish skin tears easily once hot, so tie before it goes near the oven and cut the twine away only after the fish is on the serving dish.
- BastingContinual basting was necessary in a dry coal oven. In a modern oven, add a splash of water or fish stock to the dish, baste two or three times, and tent loosely with foil if the top is colouring before the centre is done.
- YieldThree pounds with stuffing serves four to six as a main course.
Cassell's cookery titles belong to the later nineteenth century. By then ice-packed rail and steamer transport had widened the inland trade in sea fish, though quite how routine deep-sea halibut was on a given counter is harder to pin down than the flat claim suggests. Oysters had been cheap bulk food earlier in the century and were still used as a filler and flavouring in forcemeats, sauces and pies rather than treated purely as a delicacy, though English supplies were falling and prices rising through the 1870s and 1880s. Pairing a lean white fish with a rich shellfish forcemeat and then masking it with a brown meat gravy is characteristic of high Victorian cookery, which tended to build a dish in layers of savour rather than let a single ingredient speak. The instruction to bind the fish and bake it whole also suits a kitchen where a joint or a fish went into the oven with the rest of the meal and was basted by whoever was passing.