Home › The Principles of Cookery › Pickle for Meat
Pickle for Meat
Put two gallons of spring water into a large pan with five pounds of common salt, two pounds of moist sugar, and two ounces of saltpetre. Boil for twenty minutes, and skim carefully. A large round of beef would require to lie in this pickle for a fortnight before it is done. The meat will be more mellow if bay salt is used. Three pounds of bay salt may be substituted for common salt. Add one pound of common salt, or half a pound of bay salt, and a pint of water every time the pickle is boiled.
This is a wet cure — a strong salt-and-nitrate brine meant to preserve a large joint of beef over two weeks in an unheated larder. It is readable as a historical document, but it is not a procedure to follow.
- Why this cure fails todayNothing in the recipe controls temperature, and two weeks is long enough for spoilage and for Clostridium botulinum to matter if the meat sits warm. The original assumed a cold stone larder in a British winter, a condition the text never states and a modern kitchen does not supply. Curing at length requires a measured holding temperature, which this recipe does not give.
- The saltpetreSaltpetre is potassium nitrate. Two ounces in roughly nine litres of water is a far heavier dose than modern curing practice uses, and because the recipe gives no meat weight, no uptake and no rinsing step, the amount that actually ends up in the beef is unknowable — modern limits are set against the weight of the meat, not the strength of the brine. Contemporary curing uses pre-blended nitrite salts dosed against the weight of the meat for exactly this reason.
- The reused brineThe last sentence tells you to top the pickle up with salt and water and boil it again, with no limit given on how many times. Recycled brine carries bacterial load and protein from every joint that preceded it, and its salt and nitrate strength drift with each round. Boiling reduces but does not reset that.
- Spring waterThe recipe calls for untreated spring water. That is an additional and unnecessary microbiological variable in a preparation already held for a fortnight.
- Bay saltCoarse, off-white sea salt evaporated in shallow coastal pans, sold as a distinct commodity from refined "common" salt. The book says only that it makes the cure "more mellow" and does not explain why. It has no modern shelf equivalent, though coarse grey sea salt is its nearest relative.
- Moist sugarSoft brown sugar, sold damp. Not a syrup and not demerara.
- Units and vesselA British book, so gallons are imperial: two gallons is about nine litres, and the pan needed to boil it is a preserving pan or stockpot of twelve litres or more. A "large round of beef" is a cut from the hind leg, and a joint on the scale this pickle assumes is no longer sold intact at retail.
- If you want cured beefUse a current recipe with weighed cure, weighed meat and a stated refrigeration temperature. There is no adjustment to the text above that would make it sound.
Wet-cured beef was ordinary household economy in Britain long before refrigeration: a round or a brisket was traditionally said to go into the pickling tub in autumn and come out through the winter as boiled salt beef, the ancestor of both corned beef and the spiced beef still eaten at Christmas in Ireland. Saltpetre earned its place in these brines because it fixes the red colour of the meat and suppresses the organisms that make salt-cured pork and beef dangerous, for centuries before anyone identified nitrite as the active agent. What Cassell's describes is not a recipe for a dinner but a standing household procedure, a tub kept going in the larder and refreshed with more salt and water as it was drawn down. The instruction to keep boiling and topping up the same pickle is the clearest sign of the period; brine was a resource, not a disposable.