Home › The Principles of Cookery › Punch, English
Punch, English
Rub the yellow rind of a lemon with lump sugar. Put the sugar into the punch-bowl, squeeze the lemon-juice to it, add the spirits-rum and brandy-in such proportions as are preferred. Incorporate the spirits thoroughly with the sugar and lemon before pouring in the boiling water, and keep stirring the whole while this is being added. Some add Madeira or sherry.
A hot punch built in the bowl, written for someone who already knows the ratios. The instructions are sound; what they leave out is quantity.
- The hinge: oleo-saccharumRubbing lump sugar over the lemon zest strips the peel's oil into the sugar, and that oil is what carries the aroma. Use a whole lemon's worth of zest per 8-10 lumps (about 1/3 cup sugar), rub until the lumps are damp and yellow, and let them sit 20-30 minutes before going on.
- Dissolve before dilutingThe direction to incorporate the spirits with the sugar and lemon before the water is deliberate, and the recipe is emphatic about it, adding that you keep stirring the whole while the water goes in.
- Proportions, since none are givenThe old punch rhyme, one of sour, two of sweet, three of strong, four of weak, gives roughly 1 part lemon juice, 2 parts sugar, 3 parts spirit, 4 parts water. It is a rule of thumb of uncertain date rather than a documented Georgian standard, and the recipe itself leaves the rum-and-brandy split to the maker.
- Lump sugarVictorian loaf or lump sugar was cut from a cone and is close to modern white sugar cubes. Cubes work exactly as intended here; granulated sugar rubbed with a zester gives the same oil extraction with less romance.
- Boiling waterPour it just off the boil and warm the bowl first, or a cold china bowl will drop the punch to lukewarm at once.
- Madeira or sherryThe recipe says only that some add it, and does not say when; putting it in with the spirits and counting it as part of the 'strong' measure is one reasonable reading, at perhaps a quarter of the spirit volume.
- YieldA bowl built on 2 lemons, 3/4 cup sugar, 2 cups combined rum and brandy and about 3 cups water fills roughly ten small punch cups. These are the editor's own quantities, sharper in spirit and lighter in lemon than the rhyme above; the recipe gives none. It is meant to be ladled and shared, not poured into tumblers.
Punch reached England with the East India trade in the seventeenth century, and the name is generally traced to the Hindi panch, five, for the five elements of spirit, sugar, lemon, water and spice, though that etymology is traditional rather than firmly documented. By the time Cassell's was compiled in the late Victorian decades, punch had already passed its peak as fashionable drinking and settled into the role recorded here: a bowl made for a household gathering, Christmas or a supper party, with the proportions left to the host because everyone was assumed to have a preference. It is written as a method to be varied, not a fixed formula, which is exactly how punch worked for the two centuries before bar measures and the single-serve cocktail took over.