Home › Village Receipts › Chili Sauce (Twenty large ripe tomatoes one)
Chili Sauce (Twenty large ripe tomatoes one)
Twenty large ripe tomatoes, one quart onions, two sweet green peppers chopped fine, two cups sugar, four cups vinegar, one-half cup salt, one teapsoon each of ground mustard, cloves, allspice, cinnamon and black pepper; cook one and one-half hours, bottle and cork. MRS. E. S. RooT.
The mixture itself is an ordinary Victorian tomato relish, but the preservation instruction — "bottle and cork" — is the part that cannot be carried forward, and it is inseparable from the recipe as given.
- Why corking failsA cork pushed into a bottle of hot sauce is not a hermetic seal; it admits air and organisms as the contents cool and contract. Vinegar, salt and sugar are doing the preserving work here, sometimes helped by a sealing wax or a cool cellar; spoilage would have had to be watched for.
- Tomatoes sit on the acidity lineTomatoes are borderline for safe unprocessed storage — some varieties, and overripe fruit, test above pH 4.6, the threshold below which Clostridium botulinum cannot grow. The four cups of vinegar here would probably bring the batch under that line, but "probably" is the problem: no acid measurement, no heat process, and no jar seal are specified, so nothing in the method confirms it.
- No process time or temperatureThe instruction is to cook an hour and a half and bottle. There is no boiling-water bath, no headspace, no processing time keyed to jar size, and no vent-and-seal step. Current tested chili sauce recipes specify all four, and one of those should be used instead.
- Batch size is unmeasured"Twenty large ripe tomatoes" and "one quart onions" cannot be pinned to a fixed acid ratio, since tomato size and juiciness vary enormously. That variability is exactly what a canning recipe cannot tolerate, and it is why the quantities here are not adaptable by eye.
- Reading the old units, for interestTwenty large ripe tomatoes is roughly 8 to 10 lb; a quart of onions means a quart measure of chopped onion, that is 4 cups, not a quart by weight. The half cup of salt is a preserving quantity, not a seasoning one.
- What the spice list tells youGround mustard, cloves, allspice, cinnamon and black pepper in equal teaspoons is the warm baking-spice profile common to period tomato sauces generally; what distinguishes American chili sauce from ketchup is chiefly that it is chunky and unstrained, and sweeter. It is worth noting for context, not for reproducing this method.
American "chili sauce" of this period has almost nothing to do with Mexican or Southwestern chile cookery: it is a chunky sweet-and-sour tomato relish, a coarser cousin of the bottled ketchup that had been sold commercially since the mid-nineteenth century, and the green peppers rather than any hot chile are usually its only nod to the name. Recipes for it are a common feature of community fundraising cookbooks of the 1890s and 1900s, when the late-summer tomato glut demanded a use. The spice mixture uclamation cloves, allspice, cinnamon, mustard u belongs to the same tradition as spiced fruit and pickled peaches, where warm baking spices were routine in savory preserves. What dates the receipt most sharply is not the ingredients but the confident brevity of "bottle and cork," written a generation before home canning was standardized and taught as a matter of measured heat.