Home › Pickles-Relishes › Chunk Pickles
Chunk Pickles
1 oz. celery seed 1 oz. whole allspice 1 oz. stick cinnamon 7 lb. medium sized cucumbers 3 lb. white sugar 3 pt. weak vinegar Soak cucumbers in brine for three days, then drain, cut in one inch pieces and let come to a boil in weak vinegar, which is at least half water, and a piece of alum the size of a walnut. Drain and pack in jars and make syrup of 3 lb. sugar, 3 pt. weak vinegar with the spices and pour over pickles in jars and seal.
This is a classic open-kettle sweet pickle of the church-supper era, and the two features that define it — deliberately weakened vinegar and sealing jars straight from the pot — are precisely the two things modern preserving practice rules out. Read it as a document rather than a set of instructions.
- The diluted vinegar is the fatal flawThe recipe calls twice for "weak vinegar, which is at least half water." Cutting a typical 5 percent vinegar by half leaves roughly 2.5 percent acidity, which may not be enough to hold the jar below pH 4.6, the level below which Clostridium botulinum cannot grow. In a sealed, oxygen-free jar held at room temperature, that is the condition botulism requires. No adjustment to the rest of the method compensates for it.
- Open-kettle sealingPouring hot syrup over packed cucumbers and sealing is open-kettle canning, abandoned in home-preserving guidance decades ago. The jar contents never reach or hold a temperature that destroys spoilage organisms, and the seal that forms on cooling can look perfect over a contaminated jar.
- The brine is unmeasured"Soak cucumbers in brine for three days" gives no salt-to-water ratio and no temperature. A brine that is too weak, or held too warm, spoils rather than preserves; the cook using this page was expected to know a working proportion that it does not record.
- AlumPotassium alum was the standard crisping agent for pickles and appears here as "a piece the size of a walnut" — perhaps a tablespoon, though the comparison is genuinely imprecise. It is no longer recommended: it contributes nothing to safety, can impart a puckering astringency, and calcium chloride is the modern crisping salt where one is wanted at all.
- What the quantities tell youSeven pounds of cucumbers, three pounds of sugar and three pints of liquid make a large batch, sized for a cellar shelf, not a refrigerator; the recipe does not state a yield, and three pints of syrup is little liquid for that weight of cucumbers. Ounce measures of whole spice are by weight, and an ounce of stick cinnamon is a substantial handful of quills.
- If you want these picklesUse a current tested recipe from a reputable preserving authority, with full-strength vinegar at a specified proportion and a measured boiling-water process. The spice combination here — celery seed, allspice, stick cinnamon — transfers happily to such a recipe.
The multi-day rhythm of a sweet chunk pickle — brine, drain, scald, pack, syrup — suited a garden that produced more cucumbers in a fortnight than any family could eat. The long brine draws water from the flesh and firms it; the sugar-and-vinegar syrup that follows belongs to the sweet-pickle tradition that runs through American cookery from the nineteenth century onward, distinct from the plain salt-fermented dill. Alum's presence is the period marker. It appears in pickle recipes through the late 1800s and early 1900s as an accepted way to keep a cucumber crisp, and its gradual disappearance from home-canning literature over the twentieth century is one of the clearest signs of how far tested, standardized preserving guidance has moved from kitchen custom.