Home › Cooking at the Table › Panned Oysters
Panned Oysters
1 cup oysters 1 tablespoon butter White pepper 1/2 lemon 1 teaspoon parsley Salt Toast Drain and wash the oysters. Put the fat in the pan and when hot turn in the oysters, adding the juice of the lemon and the chopped parsley. The oysters should be left only until they are plumped and the gills are a little ruffled. They must not change color, or be fried in the least. Season with salt and white pepper and serve on toast. This recipe will serve three.
A chafing-dish recipe meant to be cooked in front of the diners, which is why it is timed in seconds rather than minutes. The whole dish stands or falls on stopping the heat the moment the oysters swell.
- The hinge: stop at the ruffleShucked oysters need only a brief moment in hot butter; the recipe gives no time, only a visual cue. The "gills" are the frilled mantle edge; when it curls and the body plumps, they are done. Past that they tighten and weep liquor into the pan.
- "Panned" means a chafing dish"Panned" means cooked briefly in a shallow pan -- A heavy skillet over medium-high heat suits it; a thin pan will not hold heat once cold oysters go in.
- 1 cup of oystersRoughly a dozen shucked oysters, depending on size, or about a small container of shucked meats. Buy them refrigerated in their own liquor rather than frozen, which leaches water into the pan.
- Drain and washThe washing was most likely to remove shell grit from hand-shucked oysters. With modern shucked oysters, drain them well and pick through for fragments; skip a rinse under running water, which washes away flavor. Dry them on a towel so the butter stays hot.
- Butter quantityOne tablespoon for a cup of oysters is sparing. Two gives enough emulsified pan sauce to soak the toast, which is where most of the seasoning ends up.
- White pepper, not blackProbably chosen for appearance in a pale dish; white pepper was commonly preferred in pale cream and shellfish dishes of the period. Ground white pepper loses aroma fast; use a fresh jar or the dish tastes dusty.
- ToastCut thin, toasted dry and hot, and put on the plates before the oysters go in the pan. Soft or cooling bread collapses under the liquor.
- Yield and shellfish sourcingThree servings, as the recipe states. Because the oysters are barely heated through, buy from a reputable supplier and keep them cold until the moment they hit the pan; anyone pregnant, elderly, immunocompromised or with liver disease should avoid lightly cooked oysters altogether.
Chafing-dish cookery was at its height in American middle-class homes from roughly the 1890s through the 1920s. Oysters were a staple of that repertoire, being cheap, abundant along the Atlantic and Gulf coasts, sold shucked by the quart, and cooked in under two minutes. "Panned" here simply means cooked briefly in a shallow pan with butter, distinguished by the writer from frying, which is why the instruction insists so firmly that the oysters must not color. The same period produced dozens of variations on the theme, oysters in cream, curried oysters, oysters on toast, all built on the recognition that the shellfish itself needs almost no cooking at all.